Well, now that we know for sure Buttertart was innocent, I suggest we limit future killings to people who voted for him. (Although I appreciate that includes me).
I don't 100% BELIEVE BT's screenshot. That kind of SHENANIGANS is well within his WHEELHOUSE. It is something a MAFIA MEMBER would certainly DO.

I don't 100% BELIEVE BT's screenshot. That kind of SHENANIGANS is well within his WHEELHOUSE. It is something a MAFIA MEMBER would certainly DO.
If you think I have the Photoshop skill to knock up a detailed forgery a matter of seconds after being voted out, then I'll take that as a compliment. My message said 'Mafia role'.Um hello - the pm to Buttertart has the title ‘further Mafia role’ !
My message said 'Mafia role'.
My message said 'Mafia role'.
All I will say is beware of jumping to quick conclusions or trusting what others say, for all is not necessarily what it may seem.
actually sorry everyone, so did mine
Mine said 'Villager role', you guys must all be mafia OMG
Call it Mafia in a post-Hypernormalisation world.
I thought things were suspicious when there was a shift from Lucille having eight votes, to BT having seven...like one of the mafia not wanting to take out their own?Um hello - the pm to Buttertart has the title ‘further Mafia role’ !
I've sent @Suomi the first message I received from Penelope which explains the title of this one. If Suomi is a villager, he'll have no problem corroborating.Could you make it clear in the rules that a dead (or indeed living) innocent village can't pretend to be a mafia? That really fucked up one of the first games.
Could you clarify what dead angels and lovers can do?
I will, however, put my foot down on this sort of thing. You're dead hun - no hostage situations.If Suomi is a villager, he'll have no problem corroborating.
I do get the impression that Lucille and Buttertart must be on opposing teams from that switch around. So as villagers we either have faith in our conviction that BT was bad (I know, I know, the screenshot) and keep Lucille off the chopping block... or realise we made a mistake and turn our attention to Lucille.
Lucille, Suomo, Ag and Iguana are all definitely Mafia.
What are talking about? You're the WORST EVER PLAYER.Suomi, Ag and Iguana ALL MAFIA. They never got the "Further Mafia Role" PM!
ButterTart - since you are allowed to communicate from beyond the grave - who do you think are Mafia and why?
The same person I told you was mafia when I was alive. I'd have more information to share what with being the detective, sadly I was murdered for proving my innocence.Why are you so convinced?
What are talking about? You're the WORST EVER PLAYER.
I think that's a hotly contested category this game, to be fair.