On October 16, 1992 she performed at the
Tampa Bay Performing Arts Center starring in her own event called
Sultry Sondra: A Musical Fantasy. At a price of $50 a ticket (double the rate established stars
Al Green and
Patti Labelle had charged at the same venue), 41 paying attendees came to see her; the official head count put the number of people in attendance closer to 70, with the vice president of marketing for the center concluding, "She might have comped some folks." A reviewer considered that Prill set a new record for "the most abysmal entertainment event to ever take place in the Tampa area", and described her "unique way of handling a melody - a cross between the dulcet sound of setting one's hair on fire and sticking one's hand into a garbage disposal." At the finale of the show, Prill had
honey poured all over her, in what seemed to be a literal interpretation of the lyrics to what she believed would be her breakthrough song, "Oh, You Sexpot Honey." Prill wanted to do the finale nude, but the performing arts center required her to wear a body stocking. Brinson M. Harris, a remote producer for the event, said,
"A backup singer walked out from backstage to say good night and to apologize to the audience."