Madonna Survivor: The 2000s Round 4

[POP!]

TIKTOkTIKTOkTIKTOk
gET stUPId get STUpid

beautiful lyrics beautiful gowns

20. Hey You
19. Revolver
18. Me Against the Music
17. Miles Away
15. American Pie
15. American Life
14. Give It 2 Me
12. Nothing Fails
12. 4 Minutes

 

[POP!]

Music
Love Profusion
Hollywood

 

[straightorbroken]

I absolutely love the Thin White Duke remix of Hollywood as the next Queer Eye for the Straight Guy VMAs attendee, but taking remixes out of the equation Hollywood suffers from the album's rather barren production that was a bit too inhibited by Madge not wanting the record to sound like Music (the disco side). Sorry has always been a chore in my opinion. And Jump doesn't quite get off the ground compared to the other singles here.

 

[RS]

It’s starting to get hard. When are we voting to save?

Out:
Love Profusion
Jump
WIFLFAG

 

[VV]

I always thought Nothing Fails was the one song on American Life that was universally loved.

 

[Devil]

I think it is liked but not getting proper single treatment harms it in a singles contest.

 

[jyxz]

As SorB said, if we’re discounting remixes then WIFLFAG is a dud.

So that’s in the bag as is DAD and Hollywood.

 

[funky]

I’ve just realised that Moopy thinks that Hollywood is better than Nothing Fails.

 

[VV]

Hollywood and Nothing Fails are both better than a lot of the songs here.

 

[funky]

Hollywood is the absolute stinking pits

It was her worst single ever for me until Revolver came along.

 

[Shoat]

WHERE DID CELEBRATION (HESITATION) GO?

Get Together must absolutely not be sacrificed to save the tuneless Die Another Day

 

[OutSynk]

WHERE DID CELEBRATION (HESITATION) GO?

I was REALLY hoping no one would notice.

 

[lolly]

Okay, now it's starting to get difficult.

 

[RS]

Hollywood is the absolute stinking pits

It was her worst single ever for me until Revolver came along.

I’m calling the cops

 

[POP!]

WHERE DID CELEBRATION (HESITATION) GO?

Oh oops

 

[POP!]

Celebration was added to the poll, feel free to change your vote

 

[jyxz]

swapped out DAD for Celebration

 

[Sheena]

Hollywood is great- it would have been a much better lead single than American Life.

But yes, Nothing Fails is one of the biggest wasted opportunities of her entire career.

 

[VV]

Thank goodness there are other 'Hollywood' lovers. I was thinking there was something weird about me for liking it then.

 

[POP!]

“Celebration” caught up quick

 

[RS]

Changed my vote from Jump to Celebration

 

[straightorbroken]

As SorB said, if we’re discounting remixes then WIFLFAG is a dud.

So that’s in the bag as is DAD and Hollywood.

Oh I'm totally picking and choosing for that

I'd say WIFLFAG is good enough as is, but the A&A/A&E remix being the one served to music channels (and radio?) is more equal billing than most cases so far. I just can't fathom it being voted out this early to have even begun (to fight - hi Natalia) wondering which edit counts.

 

[VV]

People really need to listen to Celebration again, to remind themselves how good it is.

 

[POP!]

"What It Feels Like for a Girl" is my favorite Music single. It would make my top four of the decade.

 

[COB]

Celebration is iconic and deserves to go through to judges' houses.

 

[AGinAg (37)]

Oh I'm totally picking and choosing for that

I'd say WIFLFAG is good enough as is, but the A&A/A&E remix being the one served to music channels (and radio?) is more equal billing than most cases so far. I just can't fathom it being voted out this early to have even begun (to fight - hi Natalia) wondering which edit counts.

That remix is the stuff of fantasy.

 

[lolly]

Changed my vote from Jump to Celebration

+1

 

[Shoat]

“Celebration” caught up quick

I should have kept quiet! I should have kept my hesitation

Oh well, if it saves Get Together and Jump...

 

[OutSynk]

People really need to listen to Celebration again, to remind themselves how good it is.

I did. Still shit.

 

[Dark Carnival]

Changed my vote from Jump to Celebration

Pffffft

 

[RS]

Pffffft

I’m not ready to jump

 

[The Unholy Ghost]

Hollywood is the absolute stinking pits

It was her worst single ever for me until Revolver came along.

It’s a right load of ponging crud. Revolver MUCH better

 

[The Unholy Ghost]

I’m amused to see that the thoughtful What It Feels Like For A Girl has more votes than glittering dog egg Celebration

 

[The Unholy Ghost]

I used to (and still do) love this mix. I think @straightorbroken might be with me on that

 

[The Unholy Ghost]

I used to (and still do) love this mix. I think @straightorbroken might be with me on that

2:39 has just SENT ME exactly like it always did. FUCKING LOVELY MATE

 

[funky]

Moopy has this round MOSTLY right. Although the 11 votes for Get Together is totally

 

[funky]

FUCKING LOVELY MATE

 

[The Unholy Ghost]

Moopy has this round MOSTLY right. Although the 11 votes for Get Together is totally

Oh it’s inexplicable. It’s so glossy and delicious. They’ll all regret it when they realise I’ve shat in their handbags

 

[straightorbroken]

I used to (and still do) love this mix. I think @straightorbroken might be with me on that

Shall we buy some chips and start terrorizing the roads for a sensible 6:29 minutes with it full blast? By the time the police arrive we'll be doing 30 with Revolver on so probably won't even get caught.