Create a Madonna GH by choosing one song from every album

[funky]

A game for Friday!

 

[VoR]

Lucky Star
Like a Virgin
Papa Don’t Preach
Like a Prayer
Vogue
Justify My Love
Erotica
Bedtime Stories
Frozen
Music
American Life
Hung Up

After this Madonna died on the way back to her home planet

 

[funky]

Borderline
Dress You Up
Live To Tell
Like A Prayer
Vogue
Justify My Love
Rain
Sanctuary
I Want You
Frozen
Don’t Tell Me
Nobody Knows Me
Get Together
Dance 2Night
Masterpiece
Ghosttown
Medellin

Lots of ballids, I don’t think mine would sell very well That middle section though

 

[funky]

Oh I forgot to include Vogue! That helps matters

 

[Sardonicus]

Lucky Star
Dress You Up
La Isla Bonita
Spotlight
Who's That Girl
Like A Prayer
Vogue
Justify My Love
Secret Garden
Secret
Don't Cry For Me Argentina
The Power Of Goodbye
Gone
Hollywood
Hung Up
4 Minutes
Masterpiece
Ghosttown
Medellin

I've thrown in one from the oft forgotten You Can Dance along with the Who's That Girl & Evita soundtracks.

 

[Shirley]

Can we have SILENT TRACKS on our compilation?

 

[Sheena]

The term GH is a complete CONTRADICTION IN TERMS, judging by the responses

 

[funky]

Well it’s your OWN GH, innit

 

[funky]

Can we have SILENT TRACKS on our compilation?

Well I would only ever listen to MDNA with the volume on ZERO

 

[AGinAg (37)]

Burning Up
Dress You Up
La Isla Bonita
Spotlight
Like A Prayer
Vogue
Deeper and Deeper
Bedtime Story
Don't Cry For Me Argentina
Nothing Really Matters
Impressive Instant
Nothing Fails
Get Together
Give It 2 Me
Girl Gone Wild
Ghosttown
Dark Ballet

 

[Jark]

Lucky Star
Like a Virgin
La Isla Bonita
Express Yourself
Vogue
Deeper and Deeper
Human Nature
Don't Cry For Me Argentina
Drowned World/Substitute For Love
Don't Tell Me
Hollywood
Hung Up
Give It 2 Me
I Fucked Up
Devil Pray
Medellín

not a bad playlist actually

 

[funky]

Quite the VARIETY from everyone

 

[Sheena]

Well it’s your OWN GH, innit

But that the VERY (anal) point. It’s either personal preference or a GH- which would be very different.

I hate being this much of a stickler for things

 

[funky]

Sheena BANNED from playing

 

[POP!]

Borderline
Dress You Up
Live to Tell
Like a Prayer
Justify My Love
Vogue
Rain
Take a Bow
You’ll See
Frozen
Gone
Die Another Day
Get Together
Heartbeat
Masterpiece
Ghosttown
God Control

 

[BoysForSeles]

This would be today’s best of:

Borderline
Angel
Live To Tell
Who’s That Girl
Like A Prayer
Erotica
Bedtime Story
Sky Fits Heaven
Paradise (Not For Me)
Intervention
Forbidden Love (COAD)
Give It 2 Me
Masterpiece
Iconic
Extreme Occident

 

[octophone]

So, is it just "what's your favourite song on the album?" or is it "what was the best hit from the album?". The latter is a much harder question, in a way.

 

[Sheena]

So, is it just "what's your favourite song on the album?" or is it "what was the best hit from the album?". The latter is a much harder question, in a way.

PRECISELY, my EQUALLY PICKY CHUM, PRECISELY!

 

[Sheena]

Or, equally, what is the most REPRESENTATIVE Madonna tracklisting...

THEY'RE ALL SO DIFFERENT

 

[Shoat]

I'm going to go with HITS only

Borderline
Material Girl
Live To Tell
Who's That Girl
Like A Prayer
Vogue
Justify My Love
Rain
Human Nature
You'll See
Frozen
Beautiful Stranger
Don't Tell Me
Love Profusion
Get Together
Give It 2 Me
I Just Don't Recognise With Your Clothes On Hahahahahaha
Girl Gone Wild
Living For Love
Medellin


I did think about being a stickler by including all of the soundtracks and the collections and the like, but got to Evita and thought "...must I?" So I've picked and been inconsistent

 

[Suedehead]

Holiday
Like a Virgin
La Isla Bonita
Like a Prayer
Erotica
Secret
Ray of Light
Music
Hollywood
Hung Up
4 Minutes
Masterpiece
Bitch I’m Madonna
I Don’t Search I Find

 

[GNL]

got to Evita and thought "...must I?" So I've picked and been inconsistent

You must love her

 

[VV]

Borderline
Dress You Up
La Isla Bonita
Who's That Girl
Oh Father
Back In Business
Rescue Me
Bad Girl
Human Nature
You'll See
Don't Cry For Me Argentina
The Power Of Good-bye
Gone
Hollywood
Hung Up
Miles Away
Beautiful Killer
Joan Of Arc
Dark Ballet

 

[POP!]

I went for personal favorites, which were mostly singles anyway. But if I was going for genuine classic GH situation, I would’ve opted for Like a Virgin instead of Dress You Up, for starters.

 

[Joseph]

Holiday
Like A Virgin
Papa Don’t Preach
Like A Prayer
Vogue
Deeper And Deeper
Take A Bow
Frozen
Music
American Life
Hung Up
4 Minutes
Give Me All Your Luvin
Living For Love
Medellin

I went by what would be considered “hits” for each album. These would not be my personal picks.

 

[lolly]

I'm with Sheena and can't do it

If I can get my head around it just being an incomplete playlist I may get back around to it.

 

[Suedehead]

Time is waiting

No hesitating

 

[Halli]

Masterpiece
Ghosttown
Medellin

Her recent albums get a bad rap but what a ending trio this is Majestic

 

[Suedehead]

I took a pee
and had a
Scream!

 

[Suedehead]

This reminds me - what if they pressed the This Is Madonna Spotify playlist on vinyl?
I think many people here would need a triple bypass

 

[funky]

My ideal vinyl scenario is Something To Remember Parts 1 and 2, the original plus all her best ballids since tben

Gold