Bop or Flop: Giving You Up

[POP!]

 

[Jark]

MASSIVE bop. a real fave of mine over the years. I was always obsessed with the video too

 

[Halli]

This was good, feels almost forgotten. I think I Believe in You overshadowed it. Xenomania isn't it?

 

[Agneeta]

Not for me.

 

[Music]

Absolute BOP but I always forget it exists.

 

[straightorbroken]

It sort of revs itself up but never truly gets going for me - the sonic splendour is most definitely there though. Made of Glass and to a much lower extent Loving You are more appealing to me. So I rate it: a blop.

 

[Suedehead]

ISSA BOP

 

[Tisch]

MASSIVE bop. a real fave of mine over the years. I was always obsessed with the video too

Absolutely THIS. The way it doesn't sit neatly in her oeuvre means I rediscover it every 6 months to a year or so and it's always a treat to hear again.

 

[Sheena]

I love it too, but the REAL issue is that they had Made of Glass sat there waiting at the time and pissed it away as a bside.

 

[straightorbroken]

Wasn't the rumour even worse, that Kylie got wind of Rachel Stevens recording it and only put it out to stop it? If so, maybe they intended it for an next album.

 

[lolly]

Bopette

 

[octophone]

I think that was the last Kylie song I bought as a single. Bop.

 

[Shirley]

A girl's gotta SUFFER for FASHION

 

[Dark Carnival]

Cute little bop!

 

[Pipo]

I never had a problem with it and she's had so much worse; Sexy Love anynone?

 

[POP!]

It sort of revs itself up but never truly gets going for me - the sonic splendour is most definitely there though. Made of Glass and to a much lower extent Loving You are more appealing to me. So I rate it: a blop.

Don’t forget BPM

 

[Jark]

It sort of revs itself up but never truly gets going for me - the sonic splendour is most definitely there though. Made of Glass and to a much lower extent Loving You are more appealing to me. So I rate it: a blop.

Don’t forget BPM

Made of Glass and BPM are so good. BPM is genuinely a missed #1 single.

I've often wondered what an album would've turned out like if she hadn't decided/been made to release a GH. all the material we've heard from those sessions suggests it would've been a gay dance pop extravaganza...

 

[POP!]

Made of Glass and BPM are so good. BPM is genuinely a missed #1 single.

I've often wondered what an album would've turned out like if she hadn't decided/been made to release a GH. all the material we've heard from those sessions suggests it would've been a gay dance pop extravaganza...

I do wonder if some of the infinite X leaks were part of that 2004-2005 era, or has that been debunked. Lose Control, Rippin up the Disco, among some other better ones sound from the same cloth as BPM.