Bring Your Love vs 4 Minutes

[Suedehead]

To me it’s not even a question but I want to see if taste skipped a generation

 

[Penelope]

Both are mid but 4 Minutes is her least dignified moment

 

[lolly]

Bring Your Love sounds like a Madonna song featuring Sabrina Carpenter. 4 Minutes sounds like a Timbaland & Justin Timberlake song featuring Madonna.

I think they are both the right side of mid, but I'll never get over her allowing herself to be a featured act on her own lead single.

 

[Loufoque]

4 Minutes is a great song, whatever you think of the context around it.

Bring Your Love is a very cute bop.

 

[lolly]

It might be a good song, but I'm judging it as a Madonna song.

 

[SvalaWuzRobbed]

Both are mid, I would argue GAYLUV is her lowest ebb

 

[Mark R 3]

Bring Your Love without a doubt.

 

[Jark]

brinyuhluh. but neither is gold.

 

[Loufoque]

I prefer to compare Bring Your Love to its actual older sister

Hey, Britney?
Are you ready?
Uh huh
Are you?

 

[Suedehead]

Bring Your Love may not be God-tier Madonna but it's certainly NOT 'mid'.

 

[ZenGiraffe]

Bring Your Love may not be God-tier Madonna but it's certainly NOT 'mid'.

if anyone else released it you wouldn't even give it a second listen!

 

[Loufoque]

I think you underestimate Suedehead

Sabrina
Madonna
I got somethin' I wanna talk about

is enough

 

[Suedehead]

if anyone else released it you wouldn't even give it a second listen!

DON'T
Comment on my IDEAS
I don't WANT your JUDGEMENT
Or your EXPECTATIONS

 

[lolly]

Bring Your Love currently playing M&S foodhall

 

[funky]

I wouldn't listen to either now, but 4 Minutes was huge for a good few weeks before it got saturated. I was over the Sabrina collab after 2 listens. So the former.

 

[Suedehead]

Bring Your Love currently playing M&S foodhall

Perfect shopping soundtrack for a CHEESE AND CELERY sandwich

 

[Suedehead]

Whereas 4 Minutes I guess would be a hoisin duck wrap

 

[OutSynk]

Bring Your Love (feat. Sabrina) > GAYLUV (feat. MAGA) > Medellin (feat. fun for 2017-2019) > 4 Minutes (feat. 2 assholes)

 

[Eddie]

I prefer to compare Bring Your Love to its actual older sister

Hey, Britney?
Are you ready?
Uh huh
Are you?

In which case it is a MASTERPIECE!

 

[straightorbroken]

Bring Your Love shuffles the sounds of Cathy Dennis, Dannii and Kym Sims, dunks them in Inner City and hangs them all up as if it were a Frida Kahlo. The video has absolutely re-framed it as an unquenchable classic.

4 Minutes was Madge running on Timabland's treadmill (speed: Timberlake).

 

[Devil]

I mean both are maybe a bit hit chasing, particularly 4 Minutes for all the reasons above.

But both I think are rather good little 8/10 pop tracks so I don’t really care.

 

[Suedehead]

Bring Your Love (feat. Sabrina) > GAYLUV (feat. MAGA) > Medellin (feat. fun for 2017-2019) > 4 Minutes (feat. 2 assholes)

 

[Pipo]

I wouldn't listen to either now, but 4 Minutes was huge for a good few weeks before it got saturated. I was over the Sabrina collab after 2 listens. So the former.

I knew I could rely on my fave POC mopsy poster funks

 

[Pipo]

In hindsight, it's just baffling Madge went rummaging through Timbaland's demo bin full of Timberlake's and Furtado scraps but hey, it did its job.

Not to mention, she looked amazing in the video.

 

[Jark]

Whereas 4 Minutes I guess would be a hoisin duck wrap

4 Minutes is so basic it'd be a BLT.

 

[Eddie]

Me Against The Music would be a cheese sandwich. Give us nothing.

 

[Eddie]

Actually ham. It would be a ham sandwich. ONLY ham.

 

[Suedehead]

Me Against The Music would be a cheese sandwich. Give us nothing.

Just cheese
On white bread

 

[Sheena]

Bring Your Love is just SO MUCH GAYER!

SABRINA?
Madonna.
I GOT SOMETHING I WANNA TALK ABOUT

 

[Dark Carnival]

I really dislike 4 Minutes, so this an easy one even if Bring Your Love is an average song.