CHRISTMASEVE

  • Thread starter Thread starter AGinAg (37)
  • Start date Start date
I had a phone call from my brother and his kids earlier - I'm going over on Sunday. I admitted quite quickly I'd been watching films with a small libation which was the right thing to do, I feel. Bruv had to ring off when his youngest started opening presents :D.
 
What’s everyone’s general consensus on Fairytale of New York? I tried to explain to my extended family that even though it’s a great song and Christmas classic I should still be able to take offence by the fact it contains a horrible slur. Most agreed, but a small minority thought I was being ‘over sensitive’.
 
I enjoyed the suggestions this year that the offending line can be replaced with “I love Diane Abbott” or, possibly even better, “You taped over Taggart”.
 
I tried to be reasonable and explain I understand that it was written in a different era and Kirsty is not directly targeting a homosexual in the song, but that as a gay man I’d rather not hear a pub full of straight men sing a long to a song that uses faggot as an insult.
 
According to certain members of my family there’s a Venn diagram I’m not familiar with, whereby there’s a certain middle ground where a straight person calling someone a faggot, is acceptable if the song reaches a certain level of musicality.
 
Last edited:
Went through A Christmas Carol to three kids, complete with voice acting and improv. What are guncles for?

I'm spent. :D Merry Christmas everyone. xx
 
Merry Christmas :D

What’s everyone’s general consensus on Fairytale of New York? I tried to explain to my extended family that even though it’s a great song and Christmas classic I should still be able to take offence by the fact it contains a horrible slur. Most agreed, but a small minority thought I was being ‘over sensitive’.

It's one of the only Christmas songs I can stand given they're all played over and over from September onwards every single year :D Hearing them slagging each other off is a breath of fresh air

Not personally offended despite leaning quite a ways over in that direction on the Kinsley scale - I think of it as telling him he resembles a meatball in gravy anyway. But I can understand it'd get awkward in some pubs etc. More bothersome is the instance in 'Money For Nothing' which does target gays.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom