Is it wrong to like Take That?

[Inner Smile]

Never any love for Greatest Day, it means so much to me

 

[Inner Smile]

Shine IS a brilliant song but everyone just thinks of the Morrisons ad. In its own way it's brilliant

 

[Marina Salty]

He could look so much better if he just got rid of the moustache, suit and some of the hair. He's just aging himself and there's no need.

Maybe he's got pointy ears

 

[Zu]

Shine IS a brilliant song but everyone just thinks of the Morrisons ad.

 

[Inner Smile]

Maybe he's got pointy ears

 

[lolly]

Greatest Day just sounds like Gary Barlow trying too hard to force an anthem to me.

Shine isn't a bad song, but Mark Owen's voice never needs to be heard.

 

[Inner Smile]

I like Mark's voice

 

[AGinAg (37)]

Shine is fucking horrible.

 

[AGinAg (37)]

Shine? SHITE more like.

 

[Inner Smile]

Might have known you'd stick your oar in

 

[AGinAg (37)]

After ignoring you for weeks? Get over yourself.

 

[Inner Smile]

 

[Zu]

I like Shine almost as much as Pray and I’ve always hated Pray

 

[Inner Smile]

How about GIANTS?

 

[Inner Smile]

You can't say a bad word about this gem

 

[Zu]

I fucking hate Never Forget

DRAB TAT

 

[Zu]

The only Take That voice I find acceptable is (shudder) Robbie’s. I have never liked how Gary sings

 

[lolly]

I don't mind Never Forget as a song at all, but Howard Donald should never be more than a backing vocalist.

 

[Zu]

I’ve always loathed Everything Changes. Having BUT YOU after the verb really grates. Also it’s TINNY

 

[Rita]

You can't say a bad word about this gem

Oh I love this one.

 

[AGinAg (37)]

I quite like

Never Forget
Patience
Rule The World
Back For Good

All the rest can do a running jump off Beachy Head.

 

[Inner Smile]

Best boyband ever

 

[Jocasta Clun]

Yes
Yes it is

 

[Inner Smile]

NORTHERN GEMS

 

[Zu]

Oh I forgot about Rule The World. I do quite like that but it would have been much better if it were sung by Robbie

 

[Inner Smile]

Lets be honest Zu you love them all

 

[Zu]

I’d swap the entire Take That back cat for THIS



Or (especially) THIS

 

[Inner Smile]

IT'S NOT BAD TO LIKE TAKE THAT

Friday's lesson

 

[Zu]

IT'S NOT BAD TO LIKE TAKE THAT

Friday's lesson

But it’s better to like SOMEONE ELSE ENTIRELY

Around The World has just set me off terribly - the twinkly piano bit before and inside the chorus always gets me - so excuse me while I sob uncontrollably for the next hour

 

[AGinAg (37)]

It's Alright is my East 17 CUT OF CHOICE

 

[Nancy]

FUCKIN VILE TRANSPHOBE HOWARD DONALD IS A CUNT

 

[Nancy]

I just don't think he's a very nice person.

 

[Zu]

Yes but do you think Rule The World would be better if it were Robbie singing? And are you grateful to them for facilitating Lulu’s comeback?

 

[AGinAg (37)]

Yes but do you think Rule The World would be better if it were Robbie singing? And are you grateful to them for facilitating Lulu’s comeback?

Lulu had already had that all important #11 smash with terribly memorable classic INDEPENDENCE.

She was well on her way to OWNING the 90s.

 

[Inner Smile]

RELIGHT MY FIRE

YOUR LOVE IS MY ONLY DESIRE

 

[Jocasta Clun]

I try not to even THINK about the TRAVESTY that was RELIGHT MY FIRE. It killed poor old DAN HARTMAN

 

[Zu]

Lulu had already had that all important #11 smash with terribly memorable classic INDEPENDENCE.

She was well on her way to OWNING the 90s.

That’ll teach me for not checking the chronology on Wikipedia

 

[Zu]

RELIGHT MY FIRE

YOUR LOVE IS MY ONLY DESIRE

I ESPECIALLY hate that one

 

[AGinAg (37)]

My Lulu top 5

 

[Zu]

I thought Independence was QUITE GOOD ACTUALLY