Katy Perry v Gaga singles showdown

[POP!]

Now that we are more than ten years removed from their debuts, whose output has held up better...

I Kissed a Girl v Just Dance
Hot n Cold v Poker Face
Thinking of You v Paparazzi
Waking up in Vegas v Eh, Eh
California Gurls v Lovegame
Teenage Dream v Bad Romance
Firework v Telephone
ET v Alejandro
Last Friday Night v Born This Way
The One That Got Away v Judas
Part of Me v Edge of Glory
Wide Awake v You & I
Roar v Marry the Night
Unconditionally v Applause
Dark Horse v Do What U Want
Birthday v G.U.Y.
This is How We Do v. Till it Happens to You
Chained to the Rhythm v. Perfect Illusion
Bon Appetite v Million Reasons
Swish Swish v The Cure
Never Really Over v Shallow

Yeah I ignored the Gaga JAZZ era

 

[POP!]

I Kissed a Girl v Just Dance
Hot n Cold v Poker Face
Thinking of You v Paparazzi
Waking up in Vegas v Eh, Eh
California Gurls v Lovegame
Teenage Dream v Bad Romance
Firework v Telephone
ET v Alejandro
Last Friday Night v Born This Way
The One That Got Away v Judas
Part of Me v Edge of Glory
Wide Awake v You & I
Roar v Marry the Night
Unconditionally v Applause
Dark Horse v Do What U Want
Birthday v G.U.Y.
This is How We Do v. Till it Happens to You
Chained to the Rhythm v. Perfect Illusion
Bon Appetite v Million Reasons
Swish Swish v The Cure
Never Really Over v Shallow

13 Katy to Gaga's 8

I probably prefer Gaga's first three albums (including The Fame Monster) to all of Katy's but Gaga has shat out some shit singles post - 2014

 

[Iguana]

I Kissed a Girl v Just Dance
Hot n Cold v Poker Face
Thinking of You v Paparazzi
Waking up in Vegas v Eh, Eh
California Gurls v Lovegame
Teenage Dream v Bad Romance
Firework v Telephone
ET v Alejandro
Last Friday Night v Born This Way
The One That Got Away v Judas
Part of Me v Edge of Glory
Wide Awake v You & I
Roar v Marry the Night
Unconditionally v Applause
Dark Horse v Do What U Want
Birthday v G.U.Y.
This is How We Do v. Till it Happens to You
Chained to the Rhythm v. Perfect Illusion
Bon Appetite v Million Reasons
Swish Swish v The Cure
Never Really Over v Shallow

16-5 to Gaga

 

[lolly]

I Kissed a Girl v Just Dance
Hot n Cold v Poker Face
Thinking of You v Paparazzi
Waking up in Vegas v Eh, Eh
California Gurls v Lovegame
Teenage Dream v Bad Romance
Firework v Telephone
ET v Alejandro
Last Friday Night v Born This Way
The One That Got Away v Judas
Part of Me v Edge of Glory
Wide Awake v You & I
Roar v Marry the Night
Unconditionally v Applause
Dark Horse v Do What U Want
Birthday v G.U.Y.
This is How We Do v. Till it Happens to You
Chained to the Rhythm v. Perfect Illusion
Bon Appetite v Million Reasons
Swish Swish v The Cure
Never Really Over v Shallow

17-4 Gaga

 

[AGinAg (37)]

I Kissed a Girl v Just Dance
Hot n Cold v Poker Face
Thinking of You v Paparazzi
Waking up in Vegas v Eh, Eh
California Gurls v Lovegame
Teenage Dream v Bad Romance
Firework v Telephone
ET v Alejandro
Last Friday Night v Born This Way
The One That Got Away v Judas
Part of Me v Edge of Glory
Wide Awake v You & I
Roar v Marry the Night
Unconditionally v Applause
Dark Horse v Do What U Want
Birthday v G.U.Y.
This is How We Do v. Till it Happens to You (???)
Chained to the Rhythm v. Perfect Illusion
Bon Appetite v Million Reasons
Swish Swish v The Cure
Never Really Over v Shallow

Amazingly an absolute wipeout for Gaga 17-4.

Mind you several times Perry would have beaten Gaga had the other song been different.

 

[Rita]

I Kissed a Girl v Just Dance
Hot n Cold v Poker Face
Thinking of You v Paparazzi
Waking up in Vegas v Eh, Eh
California Gurls v Lovegame
Teenage Dream v Bad Romance
Firework v Telephone
ET v Alejandro
Last Friday Night v Born This Way
The One That Got Away v Judas
Part of Me v Edge of Glory
Wide Awake v You & I
Roar v Marry the Night
Unconditionally v Applause
Dark Horse v Do What U Want
Birthday v G.U.Y.
This is How We Do v. Till it Happens to You
Chained to the Rhythm v. Perfect Illusion
Bon Appetite v Million Reasons
Swish Swish v The Cure
Never Really Over v Shallow

 

[RS]

I Kissed a Girl v Just Dance
Hot n Cold v Poker Face
Thinking of You v Paparazzi
Waking up in Vegas v Eh, Eh
California Gurls v Lovegame
Teenage Dream v Bad Romance
Firework v Telephone
ET v Alejandro
Last Friday Night v Born This Way
The One That Got Away v Judas
Part of Me v Edge of Glory
Wide Awake v You & I
Roar v Marry the Night
Unconditionally v Applause
Dark Horse v Do What U Want
Birthday v G.U.Y.
This is How We Do v. Till it Happens to You ????
Chained to the Rhythm v. Perfect Illusion
Bon Appetite v Million Reasons
Swish Swish v The Cure
Never Really Over v Shallow ????

 

[Cerro de Casa]

I Kissed a Girl v Just Dance
Hot n Cold v Poker Face
Thinking of You v Paparazzi
Waking up in Vegas v Eh, Eh
California Gurls v Lovegame
Teenage Dream v Bad Romance (toughest pairing - both 11/10 moments)
Firework v Telephone
ET v Alejandro
Last Friday Night v Born This Way (equally tough pairing - both -1/10 moments)
The One That Got Away v Judas
Part of Me v Edge of Glory
Wide Awake v You & I
Roar v Marry the Night
Unconditionally v Applause
Dark Horse v Do What U Want
Birthday v G.U.Y.
This is How We Do v. Till it Happens to You
Chained to the Rhythm v. Perfect Illusion
Bon Appetite v Million Reasons
Swish Swish v The Cure
Never Really Over v Shallow


Katy Perry - 14
Lady Gaga - 7

 

[Cerro de Casa]

I probably prefer Gaga's first three albums (including The Fame Monster) to all of Katy's but Gaga has shat out some shit singles post - 2014

This.

Also - I know they're omitted from this but did Gaga actually release any proper singles from the jazz album(s)?

 

[Krustmas]

I Kissed a Girl v Just Dance
Hot n Cold v Poker Face
Thinking of You v Paparazzi
Waking up in Vegas v Eh, Eh
California Gurls v Lovegame
Teenage Dream v Bad Romance (though this was difficult, Vandalism Le Pop remix would have won)
Firework v Telephone
ET v Alejandro
Last Friday Night v Born This Way
The One That Got Away v Judas
Part of Me v Edge of Glory
Wide Awake v You & I
Roar v Marry the Night
Unconditionally v Applause
Dark Horse v Do What U Want
Birthday v G.U.Y.
This is How We Do v. Till it Happens to You
Chained to the Rhythm v. Perfect Illusion
Bon Appetite v Million Reasons
Swish Swish v The Cure
Never Really Over v Shallow

 

[Halli]

I Kissed a Girl v Just Dance
Hot n Cold v Poker Face
Thinking of You v Paparazzi
Waking up in Vegas v Eh, Eh
California Gurls v Lovegame
Teenage Dream v Bad Romance
Firework v Telephone
ET v Alejandro
Last Friday Night v Born This Way
The One That Got Away v Judas
Part of Me v Edge of Glory
Wide Awake v You & I
Roar v Marry the Night
Unconditionally v Applause
Dark Horse v Do What U Want
Birthday v G.U.Y.
This is How We Do v. Till it Happens to You
Chained to the Rhythm v. Perfect Illusion
Bon Appetite v Million Reasons
Swish Swish v The Cure
Never Really Over v Shallow

10 KP 11 LG

 

[Dark Carnival]

I Kissed a Girl v Just Dance
Hot n Cold v Poker Face
Thinking of You v Paparazzi
Waking up in Vegas v Eh, Eh
California Gurls v Lovegame
Teenage Dream v Bad Romance
Firework v Telephone
ET v Alejandro
Last Friday Night v Born This Way
The One That Got Away v Judas
Part of Me v Edge of Glory
Wide Awake v You & I
Roar v Marry the Night
Unconditionally v Applause
Dark Horse v Do What U Want
Birthday v G.U.Y.
This is How We Do v. Till it Happens to You
Chained to the Rhythm v. Perfect Illusion
Bon Appetite v Million Reasons
Swish Swish v The Cure
Never Really Over v Shallow

 

[Dark Carnival]

Gaga edging it in the beginning then it’s a Katy highway

 

[Dark Carnival]

ET vs Alejandro broke my heart

 

[Raining on Me]

I Kissed a Girl v Just Dance
Hot n Cold v Poker Face
Thinking of You v Paparazzi
Waking up in Vegas v Eh, Eh
California Gurls v Lovegame
Teenage Dream v Bad Romance
Firework v Telephone
ET v Alejandro
Last Friday Night v Born This Way
The One That Got Away v Judas
Part of Me v Edge of Glory
Wide Awake v You & I
Roar v Marry the Night
Unconditionally v Applause
Dark Horse v Do What U Want
Birthday v G.U.Y.
This is How We Do v. Till it Happens to You
Chained to the Rhythm v. Perfect Illusion
Bon Appetite v Million Reasons
Swish Swish v The Cure
Never Really Over v Shallow

15 - 6 to Gaga.

Does Joanne not count? Not that it matters.

I mean, Gaga has been exceptional at times whereas Katy is just occasionally pleasing pop at best usually.

"Unconditionally" is such a triumph though.

 

[OutSynk]

I'm sorry but some of these are just way too difficult. I can't and won't do this.

 

[BoysForSeles]

Katy has always felt juvenile to me whilst Gaga spans different age groups.

 

[Yvonne Mondle]

ET vs Alejandro broke my heart

I can’t and shan’t

 

[OutSynk]

I Kissed a Girl v Just Dance
Hot n Cold v Poker Face
Thinking of You v Paparazzi
Waking up in Vegas v Eh, Eh
California Gurls v Lovegame
Teenage Dream v Bad Romance
Firework v Telephone
ET v Alejandro
Last Friday Night v Born This Way
The One That Got Away v Judas
Part of Me v Edge of Glory
Wide Awake v You & I (Mark Taylor Remix)
Roar v Marry the Night
Unconditionally v Applause
Dark Horse v Do What U Want
Birthday v G.U.Y.
This is How We Do v. Till it Happens to You
Chained to the Rhythm v. Perfect Illusion
Bon Appetit v Million Reasons
Swish Swish v The Cure
Never Really Over v Shallow

Gaga won 16-5.

 

[OutSynk]

Some CHOICES in this thread though. Roar over Marry the Night?

 

[Pipo]

Some CHOICES in this thread though. Roar over Marry the Night?

Marry the night is pure dogshit

 

[Pipo]

I Kissed a Girl v Just Dance
Hot n Cold v Poker Face
Thinking of You v Paparazzi
Waking up in Vegas v Eh, Eh
California Gurls v Lovegame
Teenage Dream v Bad Romance
Firework v Telephone
ET v Alejandro
Last Friday Night v Born This Way
The One That Got Away v Judas
Part of Me v Edge of Glory
Wide Awake v You & I
Roar v Marry the Night
Unconditionally v Applause
Dark Horse v Do What U Want
Birthday v G.U.Y.
This is How We Do v. Till it Happens to You
Chained to the Rhythm v. Perfect Illusion
Bon Appetite v Million Reasons
Swish Swish v The Cure
Never Really Over v Shallow

i do have to say, on most of these I chose Katy by default because I do loath some gaga singles

 

[OutSynk]

Marry the night is pure dogshit

Very close to hitting that report button.

 

[D5K]

I Kissed a Girl v Just Dance
Hot n Cold v Poker Face
Thinking of You v Paparazzi
Waking up in Vegas v Eh, Eh
California Gurls v Lovegame
Teenage Dream v Bad Romance
Firework v Telephone
ET v Alejandro
Last Friday Night v Born This Way
The One That Got Away v Judas
Part of Me v Edge of Glory
Wide Awake v You & I
Roar v Marry the Night
Unconditionally v Applause
Dark Horse v Do What U Want
Birthday v G.U.Y.
This is How We Do v. Till it Happens to You
Chained to the Rhythm v. Perfect Illusion
Bon Appetite v Million Reasons
Swish Swish v The Cure
Never Really Over v Shallow

The choices around 2011 were agony.

 

[Jark]

I Kissed a Girl v Just Dance
Hot n Cold v Poker Face
Thinking of You v Paparazzi
Waking up in Vegas v Eh, Eh
California Gurls v Lovegame
Teenage Dream v Bad Romance
Firework v Telephone
ET v Alejandro
Last Friday Night v Born This Way
The One That Got Away v Judas
Part of Me v Edge of Glory
Wide Awake v You & I
Roar v Marry the Night
Unconditionally v Applause
Dark Horse v Do What U Want
Birthday v G.U.Y.
This is How We Do v. Till it Happens to You
Chained to the Rhythm v. Perfect Illusion
Bon Appetit v Million Reasons
Swish Swish v The Cure
Never Really Over v Shallow

14-7 to Gaga, even though I have more time for Katy in general right now