Moopy Mafia 2020 - Day 8 - DAY PHASE

[Kate]

HI POO!

 

[big ron]

Well big ron has been very keen to back you up for starters. Pointing the finger at everyone who voted for you.

I'm not 100% convinced on Penelope to be honest, I just thought it was suspicious that all the mafia suspects jumped on one bandwagon. It's all wide open now IMO.

 

[Phoenix]

Because that is exactly what happened.

It’s admirable that you’re still trying and you get people to believe you.

 

[Dark Carnival]

HI POO!

 

[ButterTart]

The mafia have slaughtered poor @Suomi. Rest well my angel. You were loved.

And just like that it's daybreak. I think @Indie may still be out, so we can take a break before he kindly resets the poll.

WHAT? I was BEYOND CERTAIN that Suomi was Mafia. That’s an interesting tactic or a catastrophic blunder by the Mafia...

 

[Dark Carnival]

Poor Suomi, thrown under the bus by his own.

I'm no longer sure really

 

[big ron]

If Su isn't mafia, Penelope is, put it that way.

 

[big ron]

And if that is the case, Pen has played a masterclass in shithousery.

 

[Penelope]

It’s admirable that you’re still trying and you get people to believe you.

You have behaved so suspiciously all game. You do this every single time but you always end up the villager. Could it be that this time you're finally mafia?

 

[Penelope]

If Su isn't mafia, Penelope is, put it that way.

And Su was mafia.

 

[Alla]

And just like that it's daybreak. I think @Indie may still be out, so we can take a break before he kindly resets the poll.

@octophone is around and might help with that.

 

[AGinAg (37)]

@octophone is around and might help with that.

indie is here now.

 

[ButterTart]

If Su isn't mafia, Penelope is, put it that way.

Or that’s what they want us to think. The fact we have a decision this time makes me think enough of them know who the other Mafia are to form a consensus, and we’ve been led down the garden path and Su was innocent all along. I can’t see the tactical advantage of bumping off Su if they knew he was Mafia.

 

[big ron]

Or that’s what they want us to think. The fact we have a decision this time makes me think enough of them know who the other Mafia are to form a consensus, and we’ve been led down the garden path and Su was innocent all along. I can’t see the tactical advantage of bumping off Su if they knew he was Mafia.

The rumours were that Indie and Su were mafia, the mafia knew that, so by removing the rot, it removes the link to the others. It's a very tactical move if that's what happened

 

[Lucille]

Pen needs to die eventually, but I think we can wait a few rounds, let him tie himself into more knots.

 

[Penelope]

Or that’s what they want us to think. The fact we have a decision this time makes me think enough of them know who the other Mafia are to form a consensus, and we’ve been led down the garden path and Su was innocent all along. I can’t see the tactical advantage of bumping off Su if they knew he was Mafia.

Because it confuses everyone. Suomi was a goner this round - the majority that got rid of Indie would have replicated for Suomi on the same evidence. He was going to die anyway, and it makes everyone who was against them look suspicious.

But at the end of the day, it all comes down to this - if I were mafia, why would I have killed Suomi in the night and made myself look suspicious when I could have easily taken him out in the day phase now without people suspecting me?

 

[AGinAg (37)]

We also have @VoR. Could you be a love and reset the poll, removing indie and Suomi if you get a second please?

 

[K.C.]

Lucille and Suomi are so Mafia

 

[Alla]

And Su was mafia.

But if both Indie and Suomi were Mafia, that means there are another 3, and at least 2 of them had to vote for Suomi to get him killed. Is it just me, or 2 out of 3 Mafia member thinking killing one of them, the one that was bringing all the attention as they fly under the radar, was the right move, makes absolutely no sense?

 

[Lucille]

Lucille and Suomi are so Mafia

Go back to HELL.

 

[SDF]

It’s like playing a game with Jameela Jamil

 

[Penelope]

But if both Indie and Suomi were Mafia, that means there are another 3, and at least 2 of them had to vote for Suomi to get him killed. Is it just me, or 2 out of 3 Mafia member thinking killing one of them, the one that was bringing all the attention as they fly under the radar, was the right move, makes absolutely no sense?

If there are three other mafia plus Suomi, it makes complete sense if they were all flying under the radar for them to take out Suomi. There are still three of them left!

 

[Dark Carnival]

Pen needs to die eventually, but I think we can wait a few rounds, let him tie himself into more knots.

You defending Pen all of a sudden sounds just too suspicious

 

[Alla]

I want to believe you Penny, but I don't understand how that makes sense. I mean, it is possible, but it's such a risky move, worst case scenario for Mafia members now is Suomi dead, IMO.

 

[Lucille]

I've been consistent in my opinion that she's a LUNATIC who can NOT BE TRUSTED.

 

[Penelope]

I want to believe you Penny, but I don't understand how that makes sense. I mean, it is possible, but it's such a risky move, worst case scenario for Mafia members now is Suomi dead, IMO.

The worst case scenario for Mafia members is that they're all found out - not that Suomi, who was a dead man walking, is dead

 

[Lucille]

If you wanna kill her next round I'm IN, but I'm pushing for RON this round.

 

[Penelope]

Pen needs to die eventually, but I think we can wait a few rounds, let him tie himself into more knots.

You need to die now.

 

[Lucille]

You need to die now.

TRY IT HO.

 

[VoR]

We also have @VoR. Could you be a love and reset the poll, removing indie and Suomi if you get a second please?

DONE

 

[Alla]

The worst case scenario for Mafia members is that they're all found out - not that Suomi, who was a dead man walking, is dead

But that gives them an extra day to kill another villager! Come on Penny, what I'm saying makes perfect sense.

 

[AGinAg (37)]

Thanks @VoR

Right day phase is officially ON. Get voting. I need 9 votes for a kill this time.

 

[Lucille]

Pitchforks ready fellow VILLAGERS!

 

[Alla]

Ok I need to to compile some questions for FF, I need to open a new round now, tag me for anything important, I'll be around. Brb.

 

[Penelope]

But that gives them an extra day to kill another villager! Come on Penny, what I'm saying makes perfect sense.

I understand why you're concerned, but casting suspicion on me was the thing that could best save them. It would've been runaway momentum if Suomi had died this day round with few people doubting me - that indicates the other three think I'm onto them. They feel confident they can hide with the strongest lead in Suomi dead and if everyone lynches me.

 

[Penelope]

It's got to be @Lucille dead. I'm pretty sure Mother Superior is also mafia. Whether the fifth is Phoenix, Kate or dmlaw is a very open question, but I'm swaying towards Phoenix.

 

[Lucille]

Thanks for the vote Pen! As if anyone is going to trust your JUDGEMENT. It's even more BAT SHIT than CORONAVIRUS.

 

[Alla]

I understand why you're concerned, but casting suspicion on me was the thing that could best save them. It would've been runaway momentum if Suomi had died this day round with few people doubting me - that indicates the other three think I'm onto them. They feel confident they can hide with the strongest lead in Suomi dead and if everyone lynches me.

I understand what you say and it is possible, but you are forgetting there are different Mafia groups and they don't know each other, so they' re not planning anything together because they simply can't. They can't feel confident when they don't even know who they are, right?

 

[big ron]

I've got to log off for a bit to do some work/home schooling, but if anyone is wondering why Lucille is pointing fingers at me I'm going to leave this here from last night:

So if that is the case the people who were quick to vote Pen such as Lucille, Indie, Jacques and Suomi are very suspicious right now. I’ve got a feeling I’m onto something and thats why Lucille was quick round on me. I’m also worried that now I’m onto these 4 I’ll get offed in the next night phase!

If we were right about Su and Indie, and I do think we were, then Lucille's witch-hunt is very telling.

 

[SDF]

I suppose the mafia might kill one of their own IF they don't all know each other?