Moopy Mafia 2021 - Day 10 - DAY PHASE

Who do you want to kill?

  • -

  • -

  • -

  • Dark Carnival

  • -

  • -

  • -

  • Penelope

  • Phoenix

  • -

  • Rita

  • RJN

  • -

  • -

  • -

  • -

  • I'm a ghost

  • I'm dmlaw

Results are only viewable after voting.
:ghost: Several relevant players now know I was not mafia. It's almost as if lynching someone because they were PMing during a game in which people PM was a flawed strategy...
 
I've caught up. 1. I think there is a considerable chance everyone dead is a villager. 2. Jesus Christ everyone threatening to out the detective - are you on CRACK? Speaking as someone notoriously on crack, DO NOT OUT THE DETECTIVE. 3. I am profoundly suspicious of @Tisch.
 
Penelope said:
I've caught up. 1. I think there is a considerable chance everyone dead is a villager. 2. Jesus Christ everyone threatening to out the detective - are you on CRACK? Speaking as someone notoriously on crack, DO NOT OUT THE DETECTIVE. 3. I am profoundly suspicious of @Tisch.
Click to expand...
:ghost: I believe the only mafia member we've correctly lynched is Nancy.
 
They do, but they know who each other are. So he'd used it on fellow mafia if that were the case.

My theory only works if you believe I'm a villager, and seeing as I had the poison, I must be villager. Now I'm back back back back again but my poison's been used so I'm a villager with no role, but still very happy to be here.
 
Tisch said:
They do, but they know who each other are. So he'd used it on fellow mafia if that were the case.

My theory only works if you believe I'm a villager, and seeing as I had the poison, I must be villager. Now I'm back back back back again but my poison's been used so I'm a villager with no role, but still very happy to be here.
Click to expand...
How do we know you had the poison and didn't just accidentally get killed by covid? I can kind of see the beautiful masterplan now. Mafia member storms out early doors and declares he has the poison. They decide to have a Mafia kill of the person 'targeted for the poison' so it looks like they died but the 'poisoner' didn't - "look! I've definitely killed Mafia! Because I'm still alive! lol dunno what happened to the Mafia they must have just not agreed on someone". Of course a roll of the dice happens chez dmlaw's behind the scenes for who dies of covid and of all the things, it disastrously lands on you. But one of the Mafia realises how indispensable it'll seem if they revive you and make it look like you were a misguided villager who just poisoned another villager all along...
 
I could be wrong! I'm just immensely suspicious of someone declaring as fact that things went down one way "that proves we're villagers!" when they could have very conceivably happened another
 
Your scenario is possible, but mine is way more likely. It would also involve the mafia coming together and agreeing that stratagem right at the start. Really I was just sticking up for Phoenix because I was happy he revived me.

Also I was sticking up for you last night! :D to many sneks on hear :emoji_dragon::emoji_dragon: etc.
 
Tisch said:
Your scenario is possible, but mine is way more likely. It would also involve the mafia coming together and agreeing that stratagem right at the start.
Click to expand...
There were several hours between everyone finding out roles and the game starting...
 
Penelope said:
How do we know you had the poison and didn't just accidentally get killed by covid? I can kind of see the beautiful masterplan now. Mafia member storms out early doors and declares he has the poison. They decide to have a Mafia kill of the person 'targeted for the poison' so it looks like they died but the 'poisoner' didn't - "look! I've definitely killed Mafia! Because I'm still alive! lol dunno what happened to the Mafia they must have just not agreed on someone". Of course a roll of the dice happens chez dmlaw's behind the scenes for who dies of covid and of all the things, it disastrously lands on you. But one of the Mafia realises how indispensable it'll seem if they revive you and make it look like you were a misguided villager who just poisoned another villager all along...
Click to expand...

This post is long, @Suomi is going to be suspicious!
 
Penelope said:
How do we know you had the poison and didn't just accidentally get killed by covid? I can kind of see the beautiful masterplan now. Mafia member storms out early doors and declares he has the poison. They decide to have a Mafia kill of the person 'targeted for the poison' so it looks like they died but the 'poisoner' didn't - "look! I've definitely killed Mafia! Because I'm still alive! lol dunno what happened to the Mafia they must have just not agreed on someone". Of course a roll of the dice happens chez dmlaw's behind the scenes for who dies of covid and of all the things, it disastrously lands on you. But one of the Mafia realises how indispensable it'll seem if they revive you and make it look like you were a misguided villager who just poisoned another villager all along...
Click to expand...

@Tisch struggled enough to understand what on earth he was meant to do with the poison, it's making me chuckle to think he would be capable of this level of trickery (no offence @Tisch) :D
 
Iguana said:
@Tisch struggled enough to understand what on earth he was meant to do with the poison, it's making me chuckle to think he would be capable of this level of trickery (no offence @Tisch) :D
Click to expand...

and this raises my suspicion too - what a great plot twist to have a couple as the killers

and before you all joke, my sister Jessica Andersson was one of the victims at the weekend, I still struggle
 
ButterTart said:
:ghost:I have a feeling there’s too much trust and too little awareness of some of the rules...
Click to expand...
tenor.gif
 
:ghost:Who voted to kill me in the last round? Tisch, Iguana, Zengiraffe, Jiva...
Did GNL? He seemed like he was on my side but, as I say, I didn’t have time to check the list because it happened so unbelievably fast, almost as if an entire group of people belonging to, say, an organised crime family block voted for me to get rid of another innocent.
 
Tisch said:
They do, but they know who each other are. So he'd used it on fellow mafia if that were the case.

My theory only works if you believe I'm a villager, and seeing as I had the poison, I must be villager. Now I'm back back back back again but my poison's been used so I'm a villager with no role, but still very happy to be here.
Click to expand...

Is it not entirely conceivable that the mafia could sacrifice one of their own and revive them as a bluff? You came back to life pretty quick.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top Bottom