Moopy Mafia Therapy Corner

tYgoA61.gif
 
I was horrified that no-one playing last night seemed to have remembered the Dark Secret part of the game and was so pleased that you'd figured out it was a possibility this morning. When I'm encouraging people to read the rules carefully, this should be read as 'YOU'RE MISSING SOMETHING IMPORTANT, YOU FOOLS'.
 
@Indie plz explain your PM’s

I just have, but just for further clarification

Rita told you in a group convo that she had told me your questions, but for some reason everyone had ignored it and kept asking anyway.

When you PM'ed me last night, I could have told you that, but frankly i was just enjoying your bafflement and it was making me laugh no end.
 
I was horrified that no-one playing last night seemed to have remembered the Dark Secret part of the game and was so pleased that you'd figured out it was a possibility this morning. When I'm encouraging people to read the rules carefully, this should be read as 'YOU'RE MISSING SOMETHING IMPORTANT, YOU FOOLS'.
I remembered it, I just blamed the wrong person.
 
DAY BY DAY BREAKDOWN PLEASE @dmlaw

Also sorry for feeding you poison @Lucille x
DAY ONE - Rhythmbarbican LYNCHED (He had pulled out of the competition about twenty minutes after it started but you were well on the way to killing him anyway, so I just let you.)
NIGHT ONE - Lucille POISONED by Tisch, Tisch KILLED by Mafia
DAY TWO - Nancy LYNCHED
NIGHT TWO - Suomi PROTECTED by Ag, Tisch REVIVED by Phoenix
DAY THREE - ButterTart LYNCHED
NIGHT THREE - Suomi RECRUITED by Mafia
DAY FOUR - KindaCool LYNCHED
NIGHT FOUR - jivafox PROTECTED by jivafox
DAY FIVE - ZenGiraffe LYNCHED
NIGHT FIVE - Jivafox KILLED by Mafia, Kate KILLED by Covid, ZenGiraffe REVIVED by Gangsta Nancy Lam
DAY SIX - ZenGiraffe LYNCHED AGAIN
NIGHT SIX - Soldi KILLED by Mafia
DAY SEVEN - Gangsta Nancy Lam LYNCHED
NIGHT SEVEN - Indie KILLED by Mafia
DAY EIGHT - big ron LYNCHED
NIGHT EIGHT - Iguana KILLED by Mafia, Suomi KILLED by Covid
DAY NINE - Ag LYNCHED
NIGHT NINE - Tisch KILLED by Mafia
DAY TEN - Rita LYNCHED
Mafia would then kill in the night phase and outnumber the remaining villager.
 
So @dmlaw, was my vote for Rita the direct thing that caused the mafia to win?
 
DAY ONE - Rhythmbarbican LYNCHED (He had pulled out of the competition about twenty minutes after it started but you were well on the way to killing him anyway, so I just let you.)
NIGHT ONE - Lucille POISONED by Tisch, Tisch KILLED by Mafia
DAY TWO - Nancy LYNCHED
NIGHT TWO - Suomi PROTECTED by Ag, Tisch REVIVED by Phoenix
DAY THREE - ButterTart LYNCHED
NIGHT THREE - Suomi RECRUITED by Mafia
DAY FOUR - KindaCool LYNCHED
NIGHT FOUR - jivafox PROTECTED by jivafox
DAY FIVE - ZenGiraffe LYNCHED
NIGHT FIVE - Jivafox KILLED by Mafia, Kate KILLED by Covid, ZenGiraffe REVIVED by Gangsta Nancy Lam
DAY SIX - ZenGiraffe LYNCHED AGAIN
NIGHT SIX - Soldi KILLED by Mafia
DAY SEVEN - Gangsta Nancy Lam LYNCHED
NIGHT SEVEN - Indie KILLED by Mafia
DAY EIGHT - big ron LYNCHED
NIGHT EIGHT - Iguana KILLED by Mafia, Suomi KILLED by Covid
DAY NINE - Ag LYNCHED
NIGHT NINE - Tisch KILLED by Mafia
DAY TEN - Rita LYNCHED
Mafia would then kill in the night phase and outnumber the remaining villager.

That end stage just looks fucking awful.

Suomi changing sides after the detective was an almost unbreakable win condition. Almost.
 
So @dmlaw, was my vote for Rita the direct thing that caused the mafia to win?
Sorry, yes. If you, Phoenix and Rita had stuck together, one of you would have died in the night phase and the remaining two could have killed the last Mafia the next day.
 
That end stage just looks fucking awful.

Suomi changing sides after the detective was an almost unbreakable win condition. Almost.
You say that, but it was TERRIFYINGLY CLOSE at basically all times after @Suomi had no choice but to lynch GNL!
 
Can I ask why the Mafia FAILED to kill anyone for SO LONG?
You can see why!

NIGHT TWO - Suomi PROTECTED by Ag, Tisch REVIVED by Phoenix
NIGHT THREE - Suomi RECRUITED by Mafia
NIGHT FOUR - jivafox PROTECTED by jivafox
 
Can I ask why the Mafia FAILED to kill anyone for SO LONG?

We successfully killed Tisch, but then Ag used his Grauniad Angle power on Suomi, who we then tried to kill AGAIN the next day, but he just switched to us instead.

Then Jivafox used HIS angle wings to protect himself for one day.
 
DAY ONE - Rhythmbarbican LYNCHED (He had pulled out of the competition about twenty minutes after it started but you were well on the way to killing him anyway, so I just let you.)
NIGHT ONE - Lucille POISONED by Tisch, Tisch KILLED by Mafia
DAY TWO - Nancy LYNCHED
NIGHT TWO - Suomi PROTECTED by Ag, Tisch REVIVED by Phoenix
DAY THREE - ButterTart LYNCHED
NIGHT THREE - Suomi RECRUITED by Mafia
DAY FOUR - KindaCool LYNCHED
NIGHT FOUR - jivafox PROTECTED by jivafox
DAY FIVE - ZenGiraffe LYNCHED
NIGHT FIVE - Jivafox KILLED by Mafia, Kate KILLED by Covid, ZenGiraffe REVIVED by Gangsta Nancy Lam
DAY SIX - ZenGiraffe LYNCHED AGAIN
NIGHT SIX - Soldi KILLED by Mafia
DAY SEVEN - Gangsta Nancy Lam LYNCHED
NIGHT SEVEN - Indie KILLED by Mafia
DAY EIGHT - big ron LYNCHED
NIGHT EIGHT - Iguana KILLED by Mafia, Suomi KILLED by Covid
DAY NINE - Ag LYNCHED
NIGHT NINE - Tisch KILLED by Mafia
DAY TEN - Rita LYNCHED
Mafia would then kill in the night phase and outnumber the remaining villager.
AMAZING! And was there a Jiva saving Soldi in there as well? I think you mentioned during night two?
 
Can I ask why the Mafia FAILED to kill anyone for SO LONG?
The Guardian Angels succeeded on Nights 2 and 4, and night 3 was interpreted as a failure when it was Suomi's dark secret being exposed and him converting. Tischlampe was a Mafia kill - he'd have actually died the night AFTER killing Lucille with the poison, something people didn't pick up on
 
Sorry, yes. If you, Phoenix and Rita had stuck together, one of you would have died in the night phase and the remaining two could have killed the last Mafia the next day.
Sorry, yes. If you, Phoenix and Rita had stuck together, one of you would have died in the night phase and the remaining two could have killed the last Mafia the next day.
Oh FFS @RJN
 
  • Like
Reactions: RJN
NIGHT EIGHT - Iguana KILLED by Mafia, Suomi KILLED by Covid
This was the bit that made it unwinnable :D
All signs pointed to Iguana being mafia (the question is Iguana OR Phoenix a villager, when we pretty much knew Phoenix was innocent)
The fact that Suomi looked like he'd been murdered by the mafia.
 
Guardian Angels.

You can see why!

NIGHT TWO - Suomi PROTECTED by Ag, Tisch REVIVED by Phoenix
NIGHT THREE - Suomi RECRUITED by Mafia
NIGHT FOUR - jivafox PROTECTED by jivafox

We successfully killed Tisch, but then Ag used his Grauniad Angle power on Suomi, who we then tried to kill AGAIN the next day, but he just switched to us instead.

Then Jivafox used HIS angle wings to protect himself for one day.

The Guardian Angels succeeded on Nights 2 and 4, and night 3 was interpreted as a failure when it was Suomi's dark secret being exposed and him converting. Tischlampe was a Mafia kill - he'd have actually died the night AFTER killing Lucille with the poison, something people didn't pick up on

Could someone else explain to me please?
 
AMAZING! And was there a Jiva saving Soldi in there as well? I think you mentioned during night two?

No, the night I protected Soldi was the night they recruited Suomi. The only person I successfully saved was...


ME!

I so should have been Mafia.
 
This was the bit that made it unwinnable :D
All signs pointed to Iguana being mafia (the question is Iguana OR Phoenix a villager, when we pretty much knew Phoenix was innocent)
The fact that Suomi looked like he'd been lynched.
It was all a matter of interpretation - Ag had been telling everyone who'd listen that Suomi had flipped!
 
You say that, but it was TERRIFYINGLY CLOSE at basically all times after @Suomi had no choice but to lynch GNL!

Thats what should have made me more suspicious. Su had spent SO LONG saying "yeah yeah, we will do GNL next time" and constantly deflecting.
 

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom