MOOPY TRAITORS: DAY 8 - WELCOME BACK TO THE PLAY-PEN

Who should be lynched?

  • Total voters
    16
  • Poll closed .
Penelope said:
You reacted by choosing to wreck the game. I don't think I personally would have had the same wariness around giving you my number, but are you necessarily surprised some people might think you're a bit of a loose cannon who could react in a personally hostile way if you took umbrage at something they'd done, and ergo might not wish to do so?
Click to expand...
Not necessarily, but then only I know that. It felt really shitty. Looks like you've also taken umbrage.

I didn't really intend to wreck the game or achieve it. I wanted the faithful to win and thought it was useful info.
 
The rules were clear at the beginning (and have been clear across every game we've played) that the dead can't give away specific information about players. Such as, for example, info that would make various players obvious targets for the Traitors.
 
I cannot even begin to comprehend how people did, you know, LIFE, if there was a WhatsApp chat as well as the chaos going on here.

I suddenly feel a lot more empathy with Meryl than I ever thought possible.
 
Penelope said:
The rules were clear at the beginning (and have been clear across every game we've played) that the dead can't give away specific information about players. Such as, for example, info that would make various players obvious targets for the Traitors.
Click to expand...
Oh I knew I was breaking the rules! 😂
 
Penelope said:
KEY MOMENTS

- The entire castle deciding to take out cwej the detective who HADN'T EVEN BEEN ONLINE YET on the basis that he "wasn't playing so he'd be deadweight" - REALLY? You thought CWEJ WOULD BE DEADWEIGHT?! :D :D
Click to expand...
Penelope said:
- @Kratz deciding to revive @Dark Carnival, who had just been the first Traitor taken out by @Rhythmbandit? know him!'s suicide gambit (@Madison - this wasn't cheating! It's the logical thing for a Faithful to do if they're convinced they're shackled to a Traitor). I didn't consider Rhythmbandit as an actual quitter given he didn't choose to do that - everyone has the opportunity to do that as a separate action. Ergo, I considered Rhythmbandit doing this to be a conscious gambit, but I may be wrong - over to him to explain.

Either way, Kratz - an innocent Faithful Doctor - deciding to revive a Traitor was key, and meant they had pretty big strength in numbers going into the final stretch (paired with the vulnerability of the Detective being lynched at the first opportunity).
Click to expand...
- @Brandy Butters choosing to make @Madison his Mistletoe partner after the affairs - a WISE CHOICE given Madison was gunning for him (and credit if he thought Madison was a Traitor too)

- @ZenGiraffe responding to a divorce granted post-wrecking by opting for the most pleasure over business action possible, and taking out the Helena Paparizou - Survivor @Suomi - very much the Faithful equivalent of Wilfred gunning for Amanda at the first sniff of weakness rather than playing the long game, as Suomi was neither a Faithful nor a Traitor, and would have only won had he survived RIGHT until the end. In doing so rather than gunning for actual Traitors, Zen sowed the seeds of destruction for the whole castle.

- @HerSereneHighnessAnniFrid using the Chanel Suicide Jacket to take out the most dom Faithful @ZenGiraffe

- @Soldi being killed by the Traitors as their move after ZenGiraffe was saved the night before, opening the door despite a numerical advantage for a potential Faithful win...

- @Music missing the penalty shootout right at the end and not opting to save @...and a partridge Indie pear tree on the final night, instead opting to save DC :D :disco:
 
Penelope said:
- @ZenGiraffe responding to a divorce granted post-wrecking by opting for the most pleasure over business action possible, and taking out the Helena Paparizou - Survivor @Suomi - very much the Faithful equivalent of Wilfred gunning for Amanda at the first sniff of weakness rather than playing the long game, as Suomi was neither a Faithful nor a Traitor, and would have only won had he survived RIGHT until the end. In doing so rather than gunning for actual Traitors, Zen sowed the seeds of destruction for the whole castle.
Click to expand...
I REGRET NOTHING
 
Lucille said:
What was the power of the INNOCENT CHILD?
Click to expand...
A member of the castle publicly confirmed to be Faithful. The Traitors opting never to kill him was interesting! @Brandy Butters' ongoing speculation that he should be lynched if they hadn't killed him yet could've really led to a masterful gambit pay-off on the Traitors' part if that was why they left him alone, but I do think they should've killed him the night they went for ZG.
 
The DC thing is funny because a bunch of us HAD decided he was mafia, and killed RB accordingly after taking out cwej to protect him the previous night.

And then he came back and for some reason nobody ever did anything with that :D We deserved to lose!
 
Penelope said:
Oh and HerSerene was the SEXY Traitor who had the opportunity to seduce someone as a Traitor (but take them as his Lover as well), revive someone who had a 50/50 chance of becoming Faithful or Traitor, or opt for a kill and lose the power. The Traitors opted to kill ZenGiraffe, but he was saved by Music's Guardian Angel power.
Click to expand...
I told you it wouldn't be Kratz guys
(and mistook every other faithful for a traitor 💅 )
 
The @RJN thing REALLY threw me for a loop. I still can’t see the tactical advantage of the traitors keeping him in the game, since the faithful clearly took him at face value and it made him a rallying point since he was the only person the faithful could trust.

Also, I figured Madison was a traitor because of how he was gunning for me based on literally nothing (and how unquestioningly people went along with him…), and I really wanted it to be me who took him out as opposed to the other way around.
 
Penelope said:
- @ZenGiraffe responding to a divorce granted post-wrecking by opting for the most pleasure over business action possible, and taking out the Helena Paparizou - Survivor @Suomi - very much the Faithful equivalent of Wilfred gunning for Amanda at the first sniff of weakness rather than playing the long game, as Suomi was neither a Faithful nor a Traitor, and would have only won had he survived RIGHT until the end. In doing so rather than gunning for actual Traitors, Zen sowed the seeds of destruction for the whole castle.
Click to expand...

Exactly, and I had warned @ZenGiraffe to remember what was on the Swedish flag - a cross. And I was so damn cross :evil:
 
GNL said:
The DC thing is funny because a bunch of us HAD decided he was mafia, and killed RB accordingly after taking out cwej to protect him the previous night.

And then he came back and for some reason nobody ever did anything with that :D We deserved to lose!
Click to expand...
I really am the least likely to be alive, let alone win.
 
Queen of the Bethlehem 🌟 said:
Can't believe how much I was misled, almost to the last minute I thought you'd end up dead by the hands of Zen 🦒 .
Click to expand...
He was next on my list after HerSerene. Especially after the Traitors knifed Soldi after me and @Dark Carnival had discussed it, without me mentioning the full effect of his power
 
Rereading the thread, how did no one catch this error from @HerSereneHighnessAnniFrid at the time?

Screenshot_20221228-203730.png
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top Bottom