2nd: Edurne - Amanecer (165pts)
Much as I would have liked it to come down to Pastora vs Ruth for the full Alla meltdown experience*, I have to admit this probably is Spain's second-best actual effort at Eurovision this decade, even if that is rather faint praise.
Why didn't the public warm to lovely Edurne? Watching back, I really think the hideous Viennese camera angles played a huge role in bringing her down. It's more mood music than catchy pop song, so the staging really has to take you on a journey. In the broadcast, the cuts are actually ridiculous, particularly the big moment when she sheds her Red Riding Hood cloak and steps into the light, when the camera inexplicably decides to go wide so you can see the stagehand awkwardly dashing offstage with the remains of her frock
Muscle guy really is a blink and you'll miss him moment too, for all the attention he got on here. Good idea, poor execution. You really have to feel for her when she flubs the crucial last note too - she was doing really well up until that point!
4 x 12 (Kalabaliken, Penelope, Raining on Me, Tischlampe)
1 x 2 (Alla)
*although it seems he hates Edurne EVEN MORE
1st: Pastora Soler - Quedate Conmigo (215pts)
For all Spain's many failings, they really got everything right in 2012. A big star with a genuinely career-defining song, Quedate Conmigo may have only just scraped the top ten in Baku, but if Pastora's live albums are anything to go by it remains a beloved staple of her back catalogue, and it's certainly an all-time fan favourite in Euroloon circles.
It is, of course, all about the final minute, particularly but not limited to that spine-chilling money note. Imagine having to go on after that! It is a bit of a shame they didn't let her hair down, as the visage was just a touch on the harsh side, and I must admit I've never had much luck getting the casuals warmed up to this one, but I think we can all agree she was the MORAL runner-up of 2012, and ultimately she's still alive and by the end of Coronavirus all of those Russian Grannies will surely be dead, so I guess what I'm saying is that the arc of history generally curves towards justice.
12 x 12 (VoR, Pingu, Buttertart, Kevin7, David_5000, Madison, Dark Carnival, wurst, dmlaw, Alla, Ag, sewerynsven)
1 x 4 (Raining on Me)