Taylor Swift - Red (Taylor's Version) - SURVIVOR - ROUND ONE

[Iguana]

COME ON Swiffers, this forum needs some life to justify its EXISTENCE!

Pick UP TO FIVE songs you want to get the chop first. GIVE REASONS. Closes in 24 hours FIRE ROUND.

I've stuck to the main tracklist as if we did the full 30 track one, we'll all have died of Covid by the time we finish. The exception is All Too Well (10 Minute Version) as it was a single. But yes you are voting on the TAYLOR'S VERSIONS, not the originals.

 

[Jark]

OMG.

 

[Jark]

22
Everything Has Changed
Starlight

I will save my shit posting against Tr***le for later.

 

[Generic Account]

Sad Beautiful Tragic is the only one I dislike. So dull.

 

[ZenGiraffe]

I haven't listen to the songs I've chopped (why would I, if they were any good they'd have been successful singles?) so I have went with the assumption that the end of the album is where the worst songs are.

Also, who has the time to listen to a song that is ten minutes long? Get a grip.

The Ed Sh**r*n and Gary Lightbody chops needs no justification

 

[Jark]

Sad Beautiful Tragic is the only one I dislike. So dull.

oh god it's GORGEOUS!

GET OUT!

 

[Jark]

I haven't listen to the songs I've chopped (why would I, if they were any good they'd have been successful singles?) so I have went with the assumption that the end of the album is where the worst songs are.

Also, who has the time to listen to a song that is ten minutes long? Get a grip.

The Ed Sh**r*n and Gary Lightbody chops needs no justification

please listen to Begin Again hun. it's top 3.

 

[Tisch]

Why are we including All to Well (10 Minute Version) but not the other from the vault tracks please?

 

[Tisch]

I've stuck to the main tracklist as if we did the full 30 track one, we'll all have died of Covid by the time we finish. The exception is All Too Well (10 Minute Version) as it was a single. But yes you are voting on the TAYLOR'S VERSIONS, not the originals.

Hmm

 

[Jark]

Why are we including All to Well (10 Minute Version) but not the other from the vault tracks please?

as explained in the first post, it was a single

 

[Tisch]

as explained in the first post, it was a single

Hmm

 

[Iguana]

Hmm

READ THE FIRST POST

 

[ZenGiraffe]

READ THE FIRST POST

Or just click anything that contains "Ed Sh*er*n"

 

[AlgoAlex]

Or just click anything that contains "Ed Sh*er*n"

I’ve just gone for the two utterly hateful ones over anything I can’t remember

 

[Tisch]

2 votes for STARLIGHT at THIS STAGE?

Anyhoo, this is difficult. Everything Has Changed is actually lovely and works very well as a male/female duet. I just wish it wasn't him on it. The other male/female duet "The Last Time" however works extremely well for what it is, and poss features in my TayTay Top 15, so I'm not here for anyone coming for it simply because of the penis.

There really aren't many I actively dislike so this will get difficult pretty quickly.

 

[Iguana]

To be honest a lot of the last section of the album passes me by so they just have to go

 

[Iguana]

But the first half MORE than makes up for it! Plus Begin Again

 

[Generic Account]

The duets are both lovely!

 

[jivafox]

BOOT THAT GINGER BASTARD

 

[Iguana]

BOOT THAT GINGER BASTARD

 

[AlgoAlex]

The duets are both lovely!

Well The Last Time is

 

[Cerro de Casa]

Loving him is

red



(aka the 23rd best pop album of the 2010s)

 

[Jark]

guys, keep voting 22. it already has 3 votes. many of you have not been 22 for at least 22 years. together we can defeat the evil.

 

[Cerro de Casa]

Oh not Jark hating on 22 again. How very

 

[Cerro de Casa]

The duets are both lovely!

I don't know why but this post was very

 

[Iguana]

guys, keep voting 22. it already has 3 votes. many of you have not been 22 for at least 22 years. together we can defeat the evil.

But next year is 20 22???

 

[Iguana]

Also I'll likely chop a few in the first round so 22 is NOT SAFE

 

[Generic Account]

also I feel that deeming Everything Has Changed twee and basic but NOT disliking Stay Stay Stay is a bit wrong.

"ha ha ha it's so fun!"

 

[Generic Account]

not @Merry Tischmas! voting for arguable third best song Treacherous in the first round

 

[Cerro de Casa]

I'm off this PM and listening to it and loving it so much


SAD BEAUTIFUL TRAGIC is an 11/10 moment and of course a precursor to folklore don't you forget.

 

[Tisch]

not @Merry Tischmas! voting for arguable third best song Treacherous in the first round

Its position right up the top of the album always IRKS me. It's FINE, but just fine.

 

[Generic Account]

I'm off this PM and listening to it and loving it so much


SAD BEAUTIFUL TRAGIC is an 11/10 moment and of course a precursor to folklore don't you forget.

maybe this is why I find it so dull

 

[Tisch]

Can we talk about @BlitzenGiraffe🎄's votes please or are we not ready for that conversation?

 

[Generic Account]

Its position right up the top of the album always IRKS me. It's FINE, but just fine.

it's dramatic but understated!

Your name has echoed through my mind
And I just think you should, think you should know
That nothing safe is worth the drive
And I would follow you, follow you home.
I'll follow you, follow you home.

 

[Cerro de Casa]

Can we talk about @BlitzenGiraffe🎄's votes please or are we not ready for that conversation?

I started off thinking 'they're not so bad actually' but by the time I got to 'Begin Again' and 'All Too Well (TV)' I was actually in full blown

mode

 

[RJN]

Can we talk about @BlitzenGiraffe🎄's votes please or are we not ready for that conversation?

I'm personally not comfortable talking about them.

 

[RJN]

Also @Fairytale of New Jark Message In A Bottle is a single

 

[RJN]

I voted for:

Holy Ground
Sad Beautiful Tragic
The Lucky One

because I can't really remember how any of them go

 

[Cerro de Casa]

Do we think @All Iguana Xmas Is You is going to go all @Jingle POP! on us with the Britney knockout here and start fucking about with the rules???

 

[RJN]

I haven't listen to the songs I've chopped (why would I, if they were any good they'd have been successful singles?)

good job on this sentence. It has probably enraged everyone who read it