The Saturdays singles survivor - Round 4

I'm an OUTLAW, I'm a BIG BOSS, on the DANCEFLOOR


  • Total voters
    40

Tisch

DO IT FOR HER
Joined
Jun 11, 2010
Messages
45,425
Location
South Sandwich Islands
98df6b98cfd2d150259190206e78c85f.jpg


It was actually quite difficult knowing where to draw the line for this one, so sorry for making a call others may not AGREE with, but thems how it rolls sometimes.

A more even spread saw only one song getting over 50% of the vote, so Forever Is Over is over. A lead single from their second album I personally always regarded as a rather weak and odd choice. Not sure if they were going for style over substance in the form of a "catchy" chorus (which to these ears is more ANNOYING than anything), but it didn't really work. Their second single and subsequent album DELETION (:D) and brand new sharted out EP put them back on track though.

Speaking of the EP, we're also losing the lead single from that, Missing You which honestly I'm pretty shocked at. It's shimmery vibe always had it down in my head as a Mopsy fave?

We're also cutting Notorious - which is fine, there are just better versions of it in their oeuvre still to come and 30 Days (hmmmhuummmmm). So bit of a bloodbath but BLAME YOURSELVES


18 - Gentleman (31/40 votes - 77.5%)
17 - What Are You Waiting For (25/40 votes - 62.5%)
16 - My Heart Takes Over (29/41 votes - 70.7%)
15 - Issues (26/41 votes - 63.4%)
14 - Just Can't Get Enough (25/41 votes - 61%)
13 - Forever Is Over (22/40 votes - 55%)
12 - Notorious (18/40 votes - 45%)
=11 - 30 Days (17/40 votes - 42.5%)
=11 - Missing You (17/40 - 42.5%)


Top 9 time!


You can vote up to *THREE* to evict
 
If This is Love
Work
Disco Love

The last one is the only one I don’t care for, though.
 
How can anyone hate Work? In fact, that singles run from the debut makes me wanna WORK.
We are in the top half at this point so I assume not many hate it? I like it, but it's pretty run of the mill Satz without the oomph of "Up" etc. Same with "If This is Love".

"Issues" was the only real DUD of the first album singles.
 
Weirdly I can’t remember Work - I was briefly shocked to see that I hadn’t noticed it in the first few rounds. It’s on my phone so now I remember… or I did until I went to bed, and I forgot it again

I think it’s because when I hear the title I think of that Fifth Harmony song or the Ciara song
 
I just put on the debut album, and "Keep Her" and "Why Me Why Now" are 10/10 moments if I ever heard them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: dUb

Users who are viewing this thread

Back
Top Bottom