First 34 Kate Bush Singles vs first 34 Bjork singles.

Lucille

Lucille

The Grande Dame
Joined
Mar 21, 2013
Messages
56,588
Location
Hackney
Inspired by Kylie vs Madge, let's celebrate two kooky chanteuses diminishing returns. Both peaked around album 3/4 and have been infuriating us ever since. I appreciate the final 7 are going to be hard work, but bizzarely, accoridng to Wikipedia, they've both had the same amount of singles, so let's do it girls!!!

Wuthering Heights vs Human Behavior
The Man with the Child in his Eyes vs Venus as a Boy
Hammer Horror vs Play Dead
Wow vs Big Tim Sensuality
Breathing vs Violently Happy
Babooshka vs Army of Me
Army Dreamers vs Isobel
December will be Magic Again vs It's oh so Quiet :D
Sat in your Lap vs Hyperballad
The Dreaming vs Possibly Maybe
There goes a Tenner vs I Miss You
Suspended in Gaffa vs Joga
Ne t'enfuis Pas vs Bachelorette
Night of the Swallow vs Hunter
Running up that Hill vs Alarm Call
Cloudbusting vs All is Full of Love :disco:
Hounds of Love vs Hidden Place
The Big Sky vs Pagan Poetry
Don't Give Up (with Peter Gabriel) vs Coccon
Experiment IV vs It's in our Hands
The Sensual World vs Who is It
This Woman's Work vs Triumph of a Heart
Love and Anger vs Earth Intruders
Rocket Man vs Innocence
Rubberband Girl vs Declare Independance
Moments of Pleasure vs Wanderlust
The Red Shoes vs The Dull Flame of Desire
Eat the Music vs Nattura
The Man I Love vs The Comet Song
And so is Love vs Crystalline
King of the Mountain vs Cosmogony
Lyra vs Virus
Deeper Understanding vs Moon
Wild Man vs The Gate
 
Wuthering Heights vs Human Behavior
The Man with the Child in his Eyes vs Venus as a Boy
Hammer Horror vs Play Dead
Wow vs Big Tim Sensuality
Breathing vs Violently Happy
Babooshka vs Army of Me
Army Dreamers vs Isobel
December will be Magic Again vs It's oh so Quiet :D
Sat in your Lap vs Hyperballad
The Dreaming vs Possibly Maybe
There goes a Tenner vs I Miss You
Suspended in Gaffa vs Joga
Ne t'enfuis Pas vs Bachelorette
Night of the Swallow vs Hunter
Running up that Hill vs Alarm Call
Cloudbusting vs All is Full of Love :disco:
Hounds of Love vs Hidden Place
The Big Sky vs Pagan Poetry - PASS
Don't Give Up (with Peter Gabriel) vs Coccon
Experiment IV vs It's in our Hands
The Sensual World vs Who is It
This Woman's Work vs Triumph of a Heart
Love and Anger vs Earth Intruders - PASS
Rocket Man vs Innocence - PASS
Rubberband Girl vs Declare Independance
Moments of Pleasure vs Wanderlust - PASS
The Red Shoes vs The Dull Flame of Desire
Eat the Music vs Nattura - PASS
The Man I Love vs The Comet Song - PASS
And so is Love vs Crystalline
King of the Mountain vs Cosmogony
Lyra vs Virus - PASS
Deeper Understanding vs Moon - PASS
Wild Man vs The Gate - PASS
 
I dearly hope the pass on The Big Sky vs Pagan Poetry was due to their equal greatness rather than unfamiliarity?
 
Wuthering Heights vs Human Behavior
The Man with the Child in his Eyes vs Venus as a Boy
Hammer Horror vs Play Dead
Wow vs Big Tim Sensuality
Breathing vs Violently Happy
Babooshka vs Army of Me
Army Dreamers vs Isobel
December will be Magic Again vs It's oh so Quiet :D
Sat in your Lap vs Hyperballad
The Dreaming vs Possibly Maybe
There goes a Tenner vs I Miss You
Suspended in Gaffa vs Joga
Ne t'enfuis Pas vs Bachelorette
Night of the Swallow vs Hunter
Running up that Hill vs Alarm Call
Cloudbusting vs All is Full of Love :disco:
Hounds of Love vs Hidden Place
The Big Sky vs Pagan Poetry
Don't Give Up (with Peter Gabriel) vs Coccon
Experiment IV vs It's in our Hands
The Sensual World vs Who is It
This Woman's Work vs Triumph of a Heart
Love and Anger vs Earth Intruders
Rocket Man vs Innocence
Rubberband Girl vs Declare Independance
Moments of Pleasure vs Wanderlust
The Red Shoes vs The Dull Flame of Desire
Eat the Music vs Nattura PASS
The Man I Love vs The Comet Song PASS
And so is Love vs Crystalline
King of the Mountain vs Cosmogony
Lyra vs Virus PASS
Deeper Understanding vs Moon
Wild Man vs The Gate

My Sophie's Choices being

The Man with the Child in his Eyes vs Venus as a Boy
Breathing vs Violently Happy
Cloudbusting vs All is Full of Love
The Big Sky vs Pagan Poetry
The Red Shoes vs The Dull Flame of Desire
 
The best bit of Big Sky is where Kate tells the choir to 'Tell it sisters', but the choir is composed of her entirely.

Bonus round: Does Kate have any black friends?
 
I was only able to get Pagan Poetry in before the TV went back on. It was definitely Bjork. It had been a while since I heard Bjork material for the first time and it was as exciting and bizarre as I anticipated. As I may yet to hear The Big Sky, Bjork wins by default.
 
Lucille said:
Bonus round: Does Kate have any black friends?
Click to expand...
I googled this and all I found was:

16c0aa63ecc44d4ad2aaae9c3890ee3f--joan-of-arc-beautiful-people.jpg
 
The video for Pagan Poetry is quite wonderful, am I mistaken, or is the footage of her having sex actually real???
 
My favourite part is the end where the fat woman really struggle to get down onto the floor and pretend to die.
 
There's something quite sweet and endearing and English about Kate Bush, insomuch as how extraordinary her songs are, but her videos always look like community centre am-dram productions.
 
Wuthering Heights vs Human Behavior
The Man with the Child in his Eyes vs Venus as a Boy
Hammer Horror vs Play Dead
Wow vs Big Tim Sensuality
Breathing vs Violently Happy
Babooshka vs Army of Me
Army Dreamers vs Isobel
December will be Magic Again vs It's oh so Quiet
Sat in your Lap vs Hyperballad - this was brutal
The Dreaming vs Possibly Maybe
There goes a Tenner vs I Miss You
Suspended in Gaffa vs Joga
Ne t'enfuis Pas vs Bachelorette
Night of the Swallow vs Hunter
Running up that Hill vs Alarm Call
Cloudbusting vs All is Full of Love :disco:
Hounds of Love vs Hidden Place
The Big Sky vs Pagan Poetry
Don't Give Up (with Peter Gabriel) vs Coccon
Experiment IV vs It's in our Hands
The Sensual World vs Who is It
This Woman's Work vs Triumph of a Heart
Love and Anger vs Earth Intruders
Rocket Man vs Innocence
Rubberband Girl vs Declare Independance
Moments of Pleasure vs Wanderlust
The Red Shoes vs The Dull Flame of Desire
Eat the Music vs Nattura
The Man I Love vs The Comet Song
And so is Love vs Crystalline
King of the Mountain vs Cosmogony
Lyra vs Virus
Deeper Understanding vs Moon
Wild Man vs The Gate

24-9 to Kate

Love Björk to death, one of my favourite artists of all time etc. etc., but Kate is in another stratosphere
 
Lucille said:
The best bit of Big Sky is where Kate tells the choir to 'Tell it sisters', but the choir is composed of her entirely.

Bonus round: Does Kate have any black friends?
Click to expand...
She's friendly with Lenny Henry and also the fabulous Joan Armatrading. I'm sure she knows others, maybe.
 
Lucille said:
The video for Pagan Poetry is quite wonderful, am I mistaken, or is the footage of her having sex actually real???
Click to expand...
I know the shots of piercings were a stand-in, but I wouldn't be surprised if the sex was real (and of course those wonderful chebs-out shots of her which instantly make it one of the best videos ever :disco:)
 
Wuthering Heights vs Human Behavior
The Man with the Child in his Eyes vs Venus as a Boy
Hammer Horror vs Play Dead
Wow vs Big Time Sensuality
Breathing vs Violently Happy
Babooshka vs Army of Me
Army Dreamers vs Isobel
December will be Magic Again vs It's oh so Quiet
Sat in your Lap vs Hyperballad
The Dreaming vs Possibly Maybe
There goes a Tenner vs I Miss You
Suspended in Gaffa vs Joga
Ne t'enfuis Pas vs Bachelorette
Night of the Swallow vs Hunter
Running up that Hill vs Alarm Call
Cloudbusting vs All is Full of Love
Hounds of Love vs Hidden Place
The Big Sky vs Pagan Poetry
Don't Give Up (with Peter Gabriel) vs Cocoon
Experiment IV vs It's in our Hands
The Sensual World vs Who is It
This Woman's Work vs Triumph of a Heart
Love and Anger vs Earth Intruders
Rocket Man vs Innocence
Rubberband Girl vs Declare
Independence
Moments of Pleasure vs Wanderlust
The Red Shoes vs The Dull Flame of Desire
Eat the Music vs Nattura
The Man I Love vs The Comet Song
And so is Love vs Crystalline
King of the Mountain vs Cosmogony
Lyra vs Virus
Deeper Understanding vs Moon
Wild Man vs The Gate

Bjork really did fall off a cliff and some of Kate's post-Hounds work is suspiciously bland, innit?

Anyway 19 to Kate, 15 to Bjork. (edit to add totals)
 
Last edited:
COB said:
I know the shots of piercings were a stand-in, but I wouldn't be surprised if the sex was real (and of course those wonderful chebs-out shots of her which instantly make it one of the best videos ever :disco:)
Click to expand...

Just re-watching it now, forgot that the video opens with a CUM SHOT.
 
Fully nude (with strawberry laces emerging from her nipples) in the video for Cocoon, too :o
 
I'm not a huge fan of breasts, but I imagine Kate's are just as pillowy and soft.
 
Wuthering Heights vs Human Behavior
The Man with the Child in his Eyes vs Venus as a Boy
Hammer Horror vs Play Dead
Wow vs Big Tim Sensuality
Breathing vs Violently Happy
Babooshka vs Army of Me
Army Dreamers vs Isobel
December will be Magic Again vs It's oh so Quiet
Sat in your Lap vs Hyperballad
The Dreaming vs Possibly Maybe
There goes a Tenner vs I Miss You
Suspended in Gaffa vs Joga
Ne t'enfuis Pas vs Bachelorette
Night of the Swallow vs Hunter
Running up that Hill vs Alarm Call
Cloudbusting vs All is Full of Love :disco:
Hounds of Love vs Hidden Place
The Big Sky vs Pagan Poetry
Don't Give Up (with Peter Gabriel) vs Coccon
Experiment IV vs It's in our Hands
The Sensual World vs Who is It
This Woman's Work vs Triumph of a Heart
Love and Anger vs Earth Intruders
Rocket Man vs Innocence
Rubberband Girl vs Declare Independance
Moments of Pleasure vs Wanderlust
The Red Shoes vs The Dull Flame of Desire
Eat the Music vs Nattura
The Man I Love vs The Comet Song
And so is Love vs Crystalline
King of the Mountain vs Cosmogony
Lyra vs Virus
Deeper Understanding vs Moon
Wild Man vs The Gate


Kate by far then. Had this been Tori vs Kate it would have been a lot more difficult I imagine (for me at least.)
 
Wuthering Heights vs Human Behavior
The Man with the Child in his Eyes vs Venus as a Boy
Hammer Horror vs Play Dead
Wow vs Big Tim Sensuality
Breathing vs Violently Happy
Babooshka vs Army of Me
Army Dreamers vs Isobel
December will be Magic Again vs It's oh so Quiet
Sat in your Lap vs Hyperballad
The Dreaming vs Possibly Maybe
There goes a Tenner vs I Miss You
Suspended in Gaffa vs Joga
Ne t'enfuis Pas vs Bachelorette
Night of the Swallow vs Hunter
Running up that Hill vs Alarm Call
Cloudbusting vs All is Full of Love
Hounds of Love vs Hidden Place
The Big Sky vs Pagan Poetry
Don't Give Up (with Peter Gabriel) vs Coccon
Experiment IV vs It's in our Hands
The Sensual World vs Who is It
This Woman's Work vs Triumph of a Heart
Love and Anger vs Earth Intruders
Rocket Man vs Innocence
Rubberband Girl vs Declare Independance
Moments of Pleasure vs Wanderlust
The Red Shoes vs The Dull Flame of Desire
Eat the Music vs Nattura
The Man I Love vs The Comet Song
And so is Love vs Crystalline
King of the Mountain vs Cosmogony
Lyra vs Virus
Deeper Understanding vs Moon
Wild Man vs The Gate

26-8 Kate. I actually don't think she's a queen of diminishing returns at all. I love all her post The Red Shoes material to varying degrees.

Bjork on the other hand... just RETIRE.
 
Suspended in Gaffa vs Joga was probably the toughest, but Suspended... is lyrically one of my favourite Kate songs.



I won't open boxes that I am told not to
I'm not a Pandora
I'm much more like that girl in the mirror
Between you and me
She don't stand a chance of getting anywhere at all
And I want it all...
 
Ag said:
It is QUITE SOMETHING

Click to expand...


This video (and song) is obviously QUITE LUDICROUS, but I do think Kate was at her most arrestingly beautiful around the The Sensual World/ The Red Shoes eras.

I keep meaning to get this one as a framed poster for my flat.

Sensual-World-Back-%28CD-Size.jpg
 
Yeah despite it being a RIDICULOUS VIDEO (and all the better for it), I did note she looked great there.
 
VoR said:
Suspended in Gaffa vs Joga was probably the toughest, but Suspended... is lyrically one of my favourite Kate songs.
Click to expand...

Y'see, I found that a potentially tough tie but Joga might be my single favourite Bjork song. She's so open and straightforward on that song and the play on the dual meaning of emergency is exquisite.
 
VoR said:
I actually don't think she's a queen of diminishing returns at all.
Click to expand...

Me either, I very much take issue with that statement in the OP. Aerial is obviously perfection and while I can't say I go back to Director's Cut all that much (still great though), I blast 50 Words For Snow all year round

While crossing the LHAKPA-LA!!!
 
I never really got into The Red Shoes and I can see why she went back to some of the tracks from that and The Sensual World because the production is pretty flat in places. But I'll certainly stick up for 50 Words For Snow.
 
I would really defend a lot of the production choices in Directors Cut, and I think there's a lot to the fan theory that it was basically her laying the groundwork for the subsequent live show, given how many cuts from it she ended up performing.

I think I actually prefer the new versions of The Sensual World, Top of the City and (controversially) Deeper Understanding these days.
 
Yeah, that's what I'm saying, I can see why she went back to that material and reworked some tracks from the original releases.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top Bottom