Siobhan Donaghy - Ghosts

Ray Of Light mark II?

  • Total voters
    39
funky

funky

(OMF)
Joined
Apr 30, 2004
Messages
103,963
Now eligible - YAY!

I expect a slew of debates about how this is the best/dulles pop album of the decade... again...
 
As much as its more ambitious and sonically expansive than 'Revolution In Me', I think RIM is the better album. However, I do think 'Ghosts' is also quite fantastic, although to me, it feels that something is missing slightly. I can't put my finger on what.
 
1. Don't Give It Up - 10
2. So You Say - 8
3. There's A Place - 10
4. Sometimes - 8
5. 12 Bar Acid Blues - 8
6. Make It Right - 7
7. Coming Up For Air - 10
8. Goldfish - 10
9. Medevac - 8
10. Halcyon Days - 10
11. Ghosts - 10


no album gets that kind of scores treatment bar Madonna...
 
Am I the only person who just thinks it's pretty solidly good? I don't think it's amazing but I certainly don't think it's dull.

'Don't Give It Up', 'So You Say' and particularly 'There's A Place' are 11/10 masterpieces though.
 
RobotBoy said:
Am I the only person who just thinks it's pretty solidly good? I don't think it's amazing but I certainly don't think it's dull.

'Don't Give It Up', 'So You Say' and particularly 'There's A Place' are 11/10 masterpieces though.
Click to expand...

I thought you'd hate it. Most of our true pop fans just didn't get it. There are pages and pages and pages in the Siobhan thread about it. Some of the hyperbole was also off the page. I was OBSESSED...

I listed it as my fave album of 2007, just ahead of Roisin.
 
funky said:
I thought you'd hate it. Most of our true pop fans just didn't get it. There are pages and pages and pages in the Siobhan thread about it. Some of the hyperbole was also off the page. I was OBSESSED...

I listed it as my fave album of 2007, just ahead of Roisin.
Click to expand...

I don't only like pure pop, it's just such a maligned genre that I'm very vocal about my love for it.

I didn't like 'Revolution In Me' at all, but she really did something interesting with 'Ghosts'. Soncially, the whole album was spectacular and really unique.
 
what BEV said, i think time has revealed it to be a bit overproduced (just like ROL actually)
it could've done with a lot fewer beeps and bleeps, that said some amazing songs, but i too prefer RIM

1. Don't Give It Up - 10
2. So You Say - 08
3. There's A Place - 10
4. Sometimes - 09
5. 12 Bar Acid Blues - 07
6. Make It Right - 06
7. Coming Up For Air - 09
8. Goldfish - 10
9. Medevac - 07
10. Halcyon Days - 08
11. Ghosts - 08
 
1. Don't Give It Up - 08
2. So You Say - 10
3. There's A Place - 08
4. Sometimes - 07
5. 12 Bar Acid Blues - 08
6. Make It Right - 07
7. Coming Up For Air - 10
8. Goldfish - 10
9. Medevac - 04
10. Halcyon Days - 07
11. Ghosts - 11
 
oooh, medevac taking an unexpected beating...
for me i can hear a good song in there, but i REALLY have to focus to find it
 
Well it's a 9 or a 10 from me but I need time to deliberate.
 
Jonfessions said:
Tracey, Siobhan and Róisín really were the CLEVER POP TRIUMVIRATE of 2007.
Click to expand...

OMG YES

I remember being very disappointed Siobhan was not shortlisted for the Mercury Music prize. I really did think it was THAT GOOD
 
ameraal said:
what BEV said, i think time has revealed it to be a bit overproduced (just like ROL actually)
it could've done with a lot fewer beeps and bleeps, that said some amazing songs, but i too prefer RIM

1. Don't Give It Up - 10
2. So You Say - 08
3. There's A Place - 10
4. Sometimes - 09
5. 12 Bar Acid Blues - 07
6. Make It Right - 06
7. Coming Up For Air - 09
8. Goldfish - 10
9. Medevac - 07
10. Halcyon Days - 08
11. Ghosts - 08
Click to expand...

Suomi said:
1. Don't Give It Up - 08
2. So You Say - 10
3. There's A Place - 08
4. Sometimes - 07
5. 12 Bar Acid Blues - 08
6. Make It Right - 07
7. Coming Up For Air - 10
8. Goldfish - 10
9. Medevac - 04
10. Halcyon Days - 07
11. Ghosts - 11
Click to expand...

you bitches! with scores like that you should have given it a 10 :evil:
 
LOVE, LOVE, LOVE IT. It's HIGH BROW POP MUSIC at its BEST.
 
I love my loon rate of this. It's probably in my top 3 albums of all time.

01 Don't Give It Up - 10
02 So You Say - 10
03 There's A Place - 10
04 Sometimes - 09
05 12 Bar Acid Blues - 08
06 Make It Right - 09
07 Coming Up For Air - 10
08 Goldfish - 10
09 Medevac - 10
10 Halcyon Days - 07
11 Ghosts - 10

12 Man On A Misson 07
13 Re-Offend 09 (more of an interlude really)
14 Don't Take Me Back 10
15 Givin' In 07
16 Crime Of Passion 08
17 Obscured By Crowds 09 (this was meant to be from this era RIGHT?)
18 Last Request (Live) 09 (BETTER than the original)
 
Last edited:
I have Obscured By Crowds tagged as being from 2000. I'm guessing that's wrong.

What is Re-Offend? WHY DON'T I HAVE IT? :o
 
Re-Offend is a iTunes bonus track that came with Man On A Mission. It's only about 1.30 long and just repeats "If you feel that way about me, why don't you try and ask nicely? Never know how you might feel, if you try and try and try". LOVE IT.
 
Last edited:
Lee can I have all three of those bonus tracks please? I don't know any of them! (Also OT: but can I have Blow Your Cover by Girls Aloud?)

I loved this album longtime when it first came out but I haven't really dug it out in a while.

01 Don't Give It Up - 10
02 So You Say - 10
03 There's A Place - 09
04 Sometimes - 09
05 12 Bar Acid Blues - 08
06 Make It Right - 09
07 Coming Up For Air - 10
08 Goldfish - 08
09 Medevac - 09
10 Halcyon Days - 08
11 Ghosts - 10

12 Don't Take Me Back - 11

Gosh it really is very amazing. *digs out*
 
1. Don't Give It Up - 09
2. So You Say - 10
3. There's A Place - 08
4. Sometimes - 09
5. 12 Bar Acid Blues - 08
6. Make It Right - 09
7. Coming Up For Air - 10
8. Goldfish - 10
9. Medevac - 07
10. Halcyon Days - 08
11. Ghosts - 07

With 'Goldfish' being the absolute highlight for me.
 
Oh I do have Re-Offend! :bruised:

I have some BITRATE QUIBBLES though. I have these in 128kbps mp3 and would like 192kbps IF ANYONE CAN HELP:

Obscured By Crowds
Man On A Mission
Re-Offend
Don't Give It Up (Medicine8 Remix)
Don't Take Me Back
Crime Of Passion

AND THESE RIM-ERA B-SIDES:

Thus Far
Those Anythings
Instances
I'm Glad You're Mine
Don't Know Why

K THANKS
 
Why is nobody mentioning Givin' In? I group it with this album although it may be from the previous one's 'sessions'...
 
Last edited:
Oh I forgot about Don't Take Me Back & Crime Of Passion, Givin' In and Last Request *flop fan*
Don't Take Me Back is BRILL!
*adds*
 
Last edited:
Does anyone know a song called Hard To Say from the Ghosts sessions? Wikipedia has it as a leftover track.

A HQ mp3 would be nice if it exists.
 
Last edited:
Oh I loved this album, Coming Up For Air, Medevac and Ghosts are my tracks of choice, but Dont Take Me Back is my number one super fave, shame it wasn't on the album, I think it had the most hit potential too.

I wonder whether we ever will get a third album, they must have lost a bit on Ghosts - I doubt the So You Say video came cheap.

Also where are Carpe Diem and Styfling from? I have them on my laptop and they are rather grand, I cannot lie.
 
When I (drunkenly and blatantly not taking anything down as I had neither pen nor dictaphone) interviewed her she said she was definitely going to keep recording.

Although what with the credit crunch and everything she's probably down at Boots as we speak.

I NEVER understood why she didn't just tour. She reminds me of Bat For Lashes, who has built up a real grass roots following by doing small venues up and down the country for years. Siobhan already had a built-in following so I refuse to accept that she couldn't have done the same...
 
Oh yes VOR i'll g them all in an hour or so for you.
 
Jonfessions said:
Lee do you also have everything I asked for in 192? :evil:

(PLEASE :shy:)
Click to expand...

If I HAVE them in 192. If not then FUCK YOU :D

Man On A Misson and Re-Offend must be 192 as I bought them from iTunes PREMIUM or whatever it is called.
 
MAN BOY said:
Also where are Carpe Diem and Styfling from? I have them on my laptop and they are rather grand, I cannot lie.
Click to expand...

i quite love both these (esp styfling), but only have shitty bastard myspace rips
they came out during the ghosts era, but i know next to nothing about them
both tracks are by square1 (www.myspace.com/square1page) and siobhan appeared as "scarlet"... errr... OK

incidentally there are some remixes of styfling on their page right now and listening to the loose cannons one i think you will LOVE


i find it so hard to win... derogative talk come my way

:(
 
they both obviously feel like demos rather than finished tracks, innit?
 
Lee said:
12 Man On A Misson 07
13 Re-Offend 09 (more of an interval really)
16 Crime Of Passion 08
17 Obscured By Crowds 09 (this was meant to be from this era RIGHT?)
18 Last Request (Live) 09 (BETTER than the original)
Click to expand...

I don't have any of these! Can you help me out, Lee?
 
oh sorry, behind

also I love how everyone seems to have a different favourite from the whole project.
 
ooh - does anyone still have the acoustic sessions versions?

I mustn't have transfered them over when I got my new laptop :grr: the "Coming Up For Air" one was FABULOUS
 
funky said:
ooh - does anyone still have the acoustic sessions versions?

I mustn't have transfered them over when I got my new laptop :grr: the "Coming Up For Air" one was FABULOUS
Click to expand...

I do yeah.

I think you should all be paying me for Man On A Misson and Re-Offend as I actually purchased these from iTunes myself.

It's all going in the G now!
 
All done!

Plus I can't believe I put 'interval' instead of 'interlude'. Forgive me moopy. I have had too much wine.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Users who are viewing this thread

Total: 1 (members: 0, guests: 1)
Back
Top Bottom